Xenharmonic Wiki:Notability guidelines: Difference between revisions

Line 30:

* '''High complexity''': Temperaments of high complexity or EDOs with extremely high divisions (e.g. 31132edo), unless accompanied by a clear explanation of its utility or theoretical significance. This also includes temperaments and commas in impractical subgroups (e.g. 2.43.83).

* '''Minor variations''': Systems that differ only trivially from existing systems. For example, a meantone tuning with a fifth very close to quarter-comma meantone should not get its own page. It can be added to the existing tunings on the meantone page.

* '''Technical data without context''': Interval tables, temperaments, commas, or other technical data without accompanying musical explanation. ''This ~~should generally be avoided whenever possible~~.''

* '''Technical data without context''': Interval tables, temperaments, commas, or other technical data without accompanying musical explanation. ''This is the most serious issue that pages need to avoid.''

Non-notable topics with closely related notable articles can often be merged into those pages. We strongly recommend marking articles on non-notable topics with {{tlx|novelty}}, {{tlx|niche}}, or {{tlx|mathematical interest}}, as appropriate.

@@ Line 30: / Line 30: @@
 * '''High complexity''': Temperaments of high complexity or EDOs with extremely high divisions (e.g. 31132edo), unless accompanied by a clear explanation of its utility or theoretical significance. This also includes temperaments and commas in impractical subgroups (e.g. 2.43.83).
 * '''Minor variations''': Systems that differ only trivially from existing systems. For example, a meantone tuning with a fifth very close to quarter-comma meantone should not get its own page. It can be added to the existing tunings on the meantone page.
-* '''Technical data without context''': Interval tables, temperaments, commas, or other technical data without accompanying musical explanation. ''This should generally be avoided whenever possible.''
+* '''Technical data without context''': Interval tables, temperaments, commas, or other technical data without accompanying musical explanation. ''This is the most serious issue that pages need to avoid.''
 Non-notable topics with closely related notable articles can often be merged into those pages. We strongly recommend marking articles on non-notable topics with {{tlx|novelty}}, {{tlx|niche}}, or {{tlx|mathematical interest}}, as appropriate.