User:BudjarnLambeth/Cultural appropriation-o-meter: Difference between revisions

BudjarnLambeth (talk | contribs)
BudjarnLambeth (talk | contribs)
Line 165: Line 165:


"Slendric" used to be called "wonder", so maybe we can bring that name back?
"Slendric" used to be called "wonder", so maybe we can bring that name back?
===== ''Gamelic'' =====
Another name for slendric temperament but equally as bad. The term "gamelic" is very easily confused with the term "[[gamelan]]". That risks implying this temperament is identical to the ones used by gamelan orchestras. Which it is not.
Imagine saying "gamelic scales" - musicologists could easily assume you mean "scales used in gamelan music". The potential for confusion is too high.
Fortunately the name "gamelic" never really caught on and isn't widely used.


===== Possible alternative names? =====
===== Possible alternative names? =====
Line 176: Line 183:


;Difficulty of renaming - Low. I don't know of temperaments named after slendric nor much written about it, so it should be painless to change.
;Difficulty of renaming - Low. I don't know of temperaments named after slendric nor much written about it, so it should be painless to change.
====== ''Gamelic'' ======
Another name for slendric temperament but equally as bad. The term "gamelic" is very easily confused with the term "[[gamelan]]". That risks implying this temperament is identical to the ones used by gamelan orchestras. Which it is not.
Imagine saying "gamelic scales" - musicologists could easily assume you mean "scales used in gamelan music". The potential for confusion is too high.
Fortunately the name "gamelic" never really caught on and isn't widely used.


=== 3 stars (pass) ===
=== 3 stars (pass) ===