TAMNAMS/Appendix: Difference between revisions

Ganaram inukshuk (talk | contribs)
Ganaram inukshuk (talk | contribs)
Reasoning for mos pattern names: Add rewritten mos name reasonings section
Line 414: Line 414:
|}
|}
== Reasoning for mos pattern names ==
== Reasoning for mos pattern names ==
The goal of TAMNAMS mos names is to choose memorable but aesthetically neutral names.
The goal of TAMNAMS mos names is to choose memorable names for the most common octave-equivalent mosses. Generally, names should befit the mos they're describing ''no matter what temperaments support it'', allowing them to be discussed agnostically of any RTT-related contexts.


All names ending in -oid refer to an exotemperament which, when including extreme tunings, covers the entire range of the corresponding octave-period mos, such that many edos with simple step ratios for that mos will correspond to valid tunings, if not by patent val, then with a small number of warts.
Names are given to mosses that are the most likely to be used by musicians. As such, TAMNAMS primarily provides names for mosses within the range of 6 to 10 steps (or 2 to 10 steps, when including the names for smaller mosses). This range is chosen to avoid naming large mosses ''for the sake of naming''. Additionally, some of these reasonings also serve as justifications for changing earlier names. As such, this section not only provides reasonings for their names but also a record of how those reasonings were developed.
===General reasonings===
The following reasonings cover most TAMNAMS names and should be considered the minimum criteria for naming mosses.


All names for mosses with five or less notes - excluding (mono)wood and biwood (which like all n-wood mosses are specific to octave tuning) - require that some small integer multiple of the period is equal to an octave, under the reasoning that mosses with five or less notes are common and broad in tuning enough that they are much more likely to find interest in non-octave contexts. Because of this, their names were chosen to be extremely general, both to avoid bias/being too flavorful and (correspondingly) so that the terms could validly be reused for any mos for which the period is not equal to a (potentially tempered) octave.
Notable non-temperament names are incorporated into TAMNAMS if they do not cause confusion, or are given names that reference notable things. Such names include ''mosh'', ''tcherepnin'', ''archaeotonic'', ''oneirotonic'', ''balzano'', ''armotonic'', ''checkertonic'', and ''diatonic.''


Any multiperiod mos with more than five notes was given a name that wasn't reliant on the name of a mos with five or less notes as such names were based on those mos names formerly requiring an octave tuning (which is to say some small integer multiple of their period must be equal to a (potentially slightly tempered) octave).
The name of an interval or a diatonic interval quality can be incorporated into the name of a mos. Such names include ''smitonic'', ''gramitonic'', ''semiquartal'', ''subneutralic'', and ''sinatonic'', from "sharp minor third", "grave minor third", "half-fourth", "between supraminor and neutral", and the interval [[sinaic]], respectively.


Former names like "orwelloid" and "sensoid" were abandoned because the names were too temperament-specific in the sense that even considering extreme tunings did not cover the whole range of the mos. The remaining temperament-based names have been abstracted or altered heavily, namely "pine", "hyrulic", "jaric", "ekic" and "lemon".
Temperament-based names ending in the suffix ''-oid'' refer to [[Exotemperament|exotemperaments]] (low-accuracy temperametns) whose tuning ranges, when including extreme tunings, cover the entirety of their corresponding mosses. Therefore, edos with simple step ratios (2:1, 3:1, 3:2, etc) for that mos will correspond to valid tunings for that temperament (if not by [[patent val]], then with a small number of [[warts]]). Such names include ''machinoid'', ''dicoid'', and ''sephiroid'', in reference to [[machine]], [[dichotic]]/[[dicot]], and [[sephiroth]] temperaments, respectively; for information regarding these temperaments' tunings, see their specific reasonings below.


The inclusion of mos names for "multiperiod" mosses was from a desire to have all ten-note-and-under mosses named for completeness, which is also what prompted some of the reconsiderations mentioned earlier. Similarly, the inclusion of mosses of the form 1L ns using the "anti-" prefix (or an- for less-than-six-note mosses) was also for a practical consideration; although the tuning range is very unhelpful for knowing what such a mos will sound, it is nonetheless useful for describing structure in situations where one does not want to use the mathematical name, especially given that in such situations the tuning will likely be specified somewhere already. Jaric and taric specifically were chosen over bipedal and bimanual because of this, and to a lesser extent, lemon and lime were chosen over antibipentic and bipentic respectively (and for consistency with that their parent MOSS, 4L2s, is named citric).
Temperament-based names that don't refer to exotemperaments are used ''as a last resort'', and if used should be based on a notable temperament. Most of these names are abstractions of their original temperament names insofar that they refer to a temperament. Such names include ''pine'', ''hyrulic'', ''jaric'', ''ekic'' and ''lemon''; these reference the temperaments of [[porcupine]], [[triforce]], [[pajara]] (along with [[diaschismic]] and [[injera]]), [[echidna]], and [[lemba]], respectively, with ''jaric'' and ''lemon'' having additional reasonings of their own.
==== Reasonings for ''n''L ''n''s mosses====
Mosses of the form ''n''L ''n''s are given names based on a Greek numeral prefix added to the base name ''wood'', in reference to the temperaments [[blackwood]] and [[whitewood]]. These mosses are special in that all mosses with the same number of periods ''n'' can be traced back to an ''n''L ''n''s mos, representing a mos consisting of only its generators and periods. In other words, these mosses are a 1L 1s pattern repeated ''n'' times in one octave. Coincidentally, all mosses with ''n'' periods form a binary ''tree'' whose ''root'' is ''n''L ''n''s (and wood is generally known to come from trees), lending credence to the wood-based name.
====Monolarge mosses====
[[Step-generated scale|Monolarge]] mosses (mosses of the form 1L ''n''s) are given names based on their sister mos (''n''L 1s), with the ''anti-'' prefix added. The exception to this is 1L 6s, given the name ''onyx'' for the following reasonings:<blockquote>"1Ln-ic's" and "nL1-ic's (like, the -ic suffix applied to MOSS names, collectivised for 1Lns and nL1s) sounds like "one-el-en-ics" or "en-el-one-ics" which abbreviated sort of sounds like "one-ics" => "onyx". Then "onyx" sounds sort of like "one-six". Furthermore the onyx mineral comes in many colours and types, which seems fitting given this is the parent scale for a wide variety of MOSSes; specifically of interest being 7L 1s (pine), 8L 1s (subneutralic) and 9L 1s (sinatonic). Finally, the name "onyx" is also supposed to be vaguely reminiscent of "anti-archaeotonic" as "chi" (the greek letter) is written like an "x" (this is related to why "christmas" is abbreviated sometimes as "X-mas") and other than that, the letters "o" and "n" and their sounds are also present in "archaeotonic", and "x" is vaguely reminiscent of negation and multiplication. There is also something like a "y" sound in "archaeotonic" in the "aeo" part (depending partially on your pronounciation).</blockquote>Monolarge mosses were originally left unnamed due to the tuning ranges for these mosses being so large that they were unhelpful with knowing how they sound. This position was later amended as it's useful for describing structure in situations where one does not want to use the mathematical name, and especially in such contexts, a specific tuning will likely be specified.
====Malic (2L 4s), citric (4L 2s), lime (4L 6s), and lemon (6L 4s)====
The names for 2L 4s and 4L 2s come from Latin ''malus'' and ''citrus'', meaning 'apple' and 'citrus', respectively. Apples have concave ends, whereas lemons and limes – both types of citrus fruits – have convex ends. Both are ubiquitous foods, justifying their use for these fairly small mosses.


The distinction between using the prefixes "anti-" vs "an-" for reversing the number of large vs. small steps is also not as trivial as it may sound. In the case of mosses with six or more notes, as the period is always an octave, there is a very large tuning range for the 1L ns mosses (hence the original reason for omitting such mosses), but the "anti-" prefix shows that what is significant is that it has the opposite structure to the corresponding nL 1s mos while pointing out the resulting ambiguity of range. In the case of mosses with five or less notes, as the period is not known and therefore could be very small, this is not as much of a concern as fuller specification is likely required anyway, especially in the case of larger periods, so the name should not be tediously long as the name refers to a very simple mos pattern, and for related reasons, the name shouldn't give as much of a sense of one 'orientation' of the structure being more 'primary' than the other, while with mosses with more than five notes, this suggestion of sense is very much intended, because it will almost always make more sense to talk about the (n+1)L 1s child mos of whatever 1L ns mos you want to speak of.
The name ''citric'' is given to 4L 2s, as it is the parent mos of 6L 4s and 4L 6s, named after the citrus fruits ''lemon'' and ''lime'', respectively, under the reasoning that lemons are larger than limes, as are the step sizes of 6L 4s compared to that of 4L 6s.
===Name-specific reasonings===
====Pedal (1L 4s)====
Pedals are operated with feet, which have one large toe and four small toes. Also comes from words like "bipedal", where in TAMNAMS, "bipedal" would literally mean a pedal scale with a period equal to half of some chosen interval, although such a scale would have either two right feet or two left feet depending on orientation chosen. If you think "car"/"vehicle" when you think "pedal" and don't think (or want to think) much about feet then you can think about "[[beep]]ing" (as [[beep]] is the 7-limit 4&5 exotemperament). Because this name relies so heavily and fundamentally on there being 1 large and 4 small steps per period, it is appropriate to generalise for any size of period you would want. In that regard, same goes for manual, pentic and anpentic.
====Malic (2L 4s) and citric (4L 2s)====
Malic derives from Latin ''malus'' 'apple'. An apple has two concave ends, and large steps in a scale with more small steps are hole-like, hence the two large steps in malic. Citric (4L 2s) is named after the child mosses of citric, namely lemon (6L 4s) and lime (4L 6s). Unlike apples, lemons have two convex pointy ends, and small steps in a scale with more large steps are pointy, hence the two small steps. Malic and citric acids are both ubiquitous in food and biology, thus justifying their use for fairly small mos scales.
====Machinoid (5L 1s)====
[[Machine]] is the 5&amp;6 temperament in the 2.9.7.11 subgroup with a comma list of 64/63 and 99/98.


This temperament is supported by {{Optimal ET sequence| 5, 6, 11, 12, 16, 17, 22, 23, 27, 28 and 33 }} equal divisions, with non-patent val tunings including 5+5=10e, 5+10e+12=21be, 5+5+5+5+6=26qe, which are mentioned here for demonstrating virtual completeness of the tuning range, and the unusually large [[33edo]] tuning being to show [[11edo]]'s strength as a tuning.
Originally, the names for 4L 6s and 6L 4s were based on the duplication of the 2L 3s mos and were called ''dipentic'' and ''antidipentic'', respectively. These were changed to their current names as, at the time, the 5-note mosses required an octave period, thus these names required an equivalence interval of 4/1. Although the name ''pentic'' can currently apply to a 2L 3s pattern with any size period, the current names were given for completeness, which warranted renaming the related mosses of 2L 4s (renamed from ''antilemon'' to ''malic'') and 4L 2s (renamed from ''lemon'' to ''citric'').
====Onyx (1L 6s)====
"1Ln-ic's" and "nL1-ic's (like, the -ic suffix applied to MOSS names, collectivised for 1Lns and nL1s) sounds like "one-el-en-ics" or "en-el-one-ics" which abbreviated sort of sounds like "one-ics" => "onyx". Then "onyx" sounds sort of like "one-six". Furthermore the onyx mineral comes in many colours and types, which seems fitting given this is the parent scale for a wide variety of MOSSes; specifically of interest being 7L 1s (pine), 8L 1s (subneutralic) and 9L 1s (sinatonic). Finally, the name "onyx" is also supposed to be vaguely reminiscent of "anti-archaeotonic" as "chi" (the greek letter) is written like an "x" (this is related to why "christmas" is abbreviated sometimes as "X-mas") and other than that, the letters "o" and "n" and their sounds are also present in "archaeotonic", and "x" is vaguely reminiscent of negation and multiplication. There is also something like a "y" sound in "archaeotonic" in the "aeo" part (depending partially on your pronounciation).
====Subaric (2L 6s), jaric (2L 8s), and taric (8L 2s)====
====Subaric (2L 6s), jaric (2L 8s), and taric (8L 2s)====
The name "subaric" alludes to the fact that 2L 6s is the largest proper '''sub'''set mos of both j'''aric''' (2L 8s) and t'''aric''' (8L 2s).
The name ''jaric'' alludes to a few highly notable temperaments that exist in the tuning range of 8L 2s, which are alluded to through the spelling and pronunciation of '''jaric''': [[Pajara|pa'''jar'''a]], [[Injera|in'''jer'''a]], and [[Diaschismic|diaschism'''ic''']]. These temperaments, except for diaschismic, have generally inaccurate tunings.
 
The name ''taric'' was named based on it being the only named-range mos with a basic tuning (L:s = 2:1) of [[18edo]] and, as it and 2L 8s share the same parent of 2L 6s, was made to rhyme with jaric.
 
The name ''subaric'' alludes to the fact that 2L 6s is the largest proper '''sub'''set mos of both j'''aric''' (2L 8s) and t'''aric''' (8L 2s).


The name "jaric" alludes to a few highly notable and generally inaccurate (with the exception of diaschismic) temperaments that exist in the tuning range of this MOSS. Specifically, notice how the letters and sound of "jaric" has (or is intended to have) a lot of overlap with [[pajara|pa'''jar'''a]], [[diaschismic|diaschism'''ic''']] and [[injera|in'''jer'''a]] (listed in order of increasingly sharp fourths; note that diatonic fourths and 4-jarasteps are equated in jaric, a notable property).
Originally, the names for 2L 8s and 8L 2s were based on the duplication of the 3L 2s mos and were called called ''antidimanic'' and ''dimanic'', respectively (note that ''manic'' was since changed to ''manual''). These were changed for the same reasons as with 4L 6s and 6L 4s, and similarly warranted renaming the related mosses of 2L 6s (renamed from ''antiechidnoid'' to ''subaric'') and 6L 2s (renamed from ''echidnoid'' to ''ekic'').
{| class="wikitable"
|+Two-period mosses and name changes
!Pattern
!Name
!Pattern
!Name
!Pattern
!Name
! Pattern
!Name
|-
| rowspan="5" |''2L 2s''
| rowspan="5" |biwood
''(formerly unnamed)''
| rowspan="2" |4L 2s
| rowspan="2" |citric
''(formerly lemon)''
|4L 6s
|lime
''(formerly dipentic)''
|
|
|-
|6L 4s
|lemon
''(formerly antidipentic)''
|
|
|-
| rowspan="3" |2L 4s
| rowspan="3" |malic
''(formerly antilemon)''
|6L 2s
|ekic
''(formerly echidnoid)''
|
|
|-
| rowspan="2" |2L 6s
| rowspan="2" |subaric
''(formerly antiechidnoid)''
|8L 2s
| taric
''(formerly antidimanic)''
|-
|2L 8s
|jaric
''(formerly dimanic)''
|}
===Reasonings for specific names ===
====Machinoid (5L 1s)====
[[Machine]] is the 5&amp;6 temperament in the 2.9.7.11 subgroup with a comma list of 64/63 and 99/98.


The name "taric" was named based on it being the only octave-tuned TAMNAMS pattern with a [[#Simple step ratios|basic]] tuning of [[18edo]] (because [[7L 4s]] has more than 10 notes so is out of the scope of TAMNAMS, although not necessarily out of the scope of extensions) and it was also named based on rhyming with jaric (as they share the parent mos [[2L 6s]]).
This temperament is supported by {{Optimal ET sequence| 5, 6, 11, 12, 16, 17, 22, 23, 27, 28 and 33 }} equal divisions, many of which correspond to both simple tunings (L:s = 2:1, 3:1, 3:2, etc) and degenerate tunings (L:s = 1:1 or 1:0) for 5L 1s. Non-patent val tunings include 5+5=10e, 5+10e+12=21be, 5+5+5+5+6=26qe; these are mentioned here for demonstrating virtual completeness of the tuning range, as is 33edo to show 11edo's strength as a tuning.
====Sephiroid (3L 7s)====
====Sephiroid (3L 7s)====
[[Sephiroth]] is the 3&amp;10 temperament in the 2.5.11.13.17.21 subgroup with commas including 65/64, 85/84, 105/104, 169/168, 170/169, 221/220, 273/272, 275/273.
[[Sephiroth]] is the 3&amp;10 temperament in the 2.5.11.13.17.21 subgroup with commas including 65/64, 85/84, 105/104, 169/168, 170/169, 221/220, 273/272, 275/273.


This temperament is supported by {{Optimal ET sequence| 3, 10, 13, 16, 23 and 26 }} equal divisions, with non-patent val tunings including 6eg, 7e*, 19eg, 20e, 29g, 32egq, 33ce, 36c.
This temperament is supported by {{Optimal ET sequence| 3, 10, 13, 16, 23 and 26 }} equal divisions, with non-patent val tunings including 6eg, 7e, 19eg, 20e, 29g, 32egq, 33ce, 36c. Like with that of 5L 1s, these represent both simple and degenerate tunings for 3L 7s. Extreme tunings, such as 7e, may lie outside the mos's step ratio spectrum, although such tunings are generally not considered good tunings.
 
<nowiki>*</nowiki> Extreme tunings even occasionally go outside of this range like with 7e, but this would never be considered a good tuning.
 
(Note that ''q'' in the above is a placeholder symbol meaning that the generator 21 is warted.)
 
Note therefore how practically a full range of tunings is covered both in breadth and depth.
====Dicoid (7L 3s)====
====Dicoid (7L 3s)====
[[Dicot family#Dichotic|Dichotic]] is the 7&amp;10 temerament in the 11-limit with commas including 25/24, 45/44, 55/54, 56/55, 64/63 and is an extension of the 5-limit exotemperament [[dicot]] which tempers 25/24, equating 5/4 and 6/5 into a neutral third sized interval, which is the generator. To help justify using these temperament for inspiration for the name, note that:
[[Dicot family#Dichotic|Dichotic]] is the 7&amp;10 temperament in the 11-limit with commas including 25/24, 45/44, 55/54, 56/55, 64/63. This is an extension of the 5-limit exotemperament [[dicot]] which tempers 25/24, equating 5/4 and 6/5 into a neutral third sized interval, which is the generator.
 
This temperament is supported by {{Optimal ET sequence| 7, 10 and 17 }} equal divisions, with non-patent val tunings including 14cd(=7+7), 20e(=10+10), 24cd(=17+7), 27ce(=17+10).


Note there are many more warted tunings than this with even more extreme tunings, which makes it reasonable to loosely associate the exotemperament with the range of vaguely saner tunings.
This temperament is supported by {{Optimal ET sequence| 7, 10 and 17 }} equal divisions, with non-patent val tunings including (but not limited to) 7+7=14cd, 10+10=20e, 17+7=24cd, and 17+10=27ce.
====Armotonic (7L 2s)====
====Armotonic (7L 2s)====
The name "superdiatonic" has seen some precedent of use on the Xen Wiki to refer to the mos pattern 7L 2s, so is accepted as ''a'' possible name, but "armotonic" is preferred due to its clarity as "superdiatonic" could reasonably be confused as describing sharp-fifth diatonic scales. This mos is part of a series of mos patterns (5+2k)L 2s, which starts with diatonic (5L 2s, k=0) and superdiatonic (7L 2s, k=1), hence the reasoning for that name; like 5L 2s, 7L 2s is also a fifth-generated scale and has a structure similar to diatonic in some ways, but with more large steps. Because of the ambiguity, the name "armotonic", in reference to Armodue theory, is TAMNAMS' recommended name, but "superdiatonic" is allowed in contexts where it's truly unambiguous if the writer prefers it.
Originally, the name ''superdiatonic'' was used for 7L 2s, as it has seen some precedent of use on the wiki to refer to an octave-equivalent 7L 2s pattern, although it has had earlier use to refer to the expansion of a smaller mos to a larger one. Due to these concerns, the name ''armotonic'' is normally advised over ''superdiatonic'' as the former is unambiguous as to what it refers to, and the name ''superdiatonic'' is only allowed in situations where it's truly unambiguous if the writer prefers it.
 
====On the term ''diatonic''====
====On the term ''diatonic''====
In TAMNAMS, ''diatonic'' exclusively refers to 5L 2s. This is because while diatonic has accrued a variety of exact meanings over time, it has a clear choice of referent when talking about MOS scales: 5L 2s with an octave or tempered-octave period.
Although the term ''diatonic'' has accrued a variety of exact meanings over time, both within and outside the contexts of xenharmonic music theory, in the context of TAMNAMS and moment-of-symmetry scales, the term ''diatonic'' exclusively refers to 5L 2s.
 
[[Category:TAMNAMS]]
[[Category:TAMNAMS]]