User:BudjarnLambeth/Cultural appropriation-o-meter: Difference between revisions
| Line 66: | Line 66: | ||
=== Rating system === | === Rating system === | ||
;Passing grade, the name should be kept | |||
* '''5 stars''' = Respectful name that encourages people to check out the tradition which inspired it, without claiming to be identical to that tradition | * '''5 stars''' = Respectful name that encourages people to check out the tradition which inspired it, without claiming to be identical to that tradition | ||
* '''4 stars''' = Respectful name with slight flaws, which encourages people to check out the tradition which inspired it, without claiming to be identical to that tradition | * '''4 stars''' = Respectful name with slight flaws, which encourages people to check out the tradition which inspired it, without claiming to be identical to that tradition | ||
* '''3 stars''' = Name with substantial flaws, but substantial good points as well | * '''3 stars''' = Name with substantial flaws, but substantial good points as well | ||
;Failing grade, the name should be changed | |||
* '''2 stars''' = Name that seriously risks misrepresenting a tradition or falsely claiming credit for that tradition, or risks stealing from a tradition without giving credit | * '''2 stars''' = Name that seriously risks misrepresenting a tradition or falsely claiming credit for that tradition, or risks stealing from a tradition without giving credit | ||
* '''1 stars''' = Name that misrepresents a tradition or falsely claims credit for that tradition, or which steals from a tradition without giving credit | * '''1 stars''' = Name that misrepresents a tradition or falsely claims credit for that tradition, or which steals from a tradition without giving credit | ||
=== 1 star (fail) === | === 1 star (fail) === | ||