The Riemann zeta function and tuning: Difference between revisions
ArrowHead294 (talk | contribs) |
ArrowHead294 (talk | contribs) m Escapes not needed here |
||
| Line 49: | Line 49: | ||
=== Into the critical strip === | === Into the critical strip === | ||
So long as {{nowrap|''s'' & | So long as {{nowrap|''s'' ≤ 1}}, the absolute value of the zeta function can be seen as a relative error measurement. However, the rationale for that view of things departs when {{nowrap|''s'' < 1}}, particularly in the [http://mathworld.wolfram.com/CriticalStrip.html critical strip], when {{nowrap|0 < ''s'' < 1}}. As s approaches the value {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} {{frac|2}}}} of the [http://mathworld.wolfram.com/CriticalLine.html critical line], the information content, so to speak, of the zeta function concerning higher primes increases and it behaves increasingly like a badness measure (or more correctly, since we have inverted it, like a goodness measure.) The quasi-symmetric [https://planetmath.org/encyclopedia/FunctionalEquationOfTheRiemannZetaFunction.html functional equation] of the zeta function tells us that past the critical line the information content starts to decrease again, with {{nowrap|1 − ''s''}} and ''s'' having the same information content. Hence it is the zeta function between {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} {{frac|1|2}}}} and {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} 1}}, and especially the zeta function along the critical line {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} {{frac|1|2}}}}, which is of the most interest. | ||
As {{nowrap|''s'' > 1}} gets larger, the Dirichlet series for the zeta function is increasingly dominated by the 2 term, getting ever closer to simply {{nowrap|1 + 2<sup>−''z''</sup>}}, which approaches 1 as {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} Re(''z'')}} becomes larger. When {{nowrap|''s'' >> 1}} and ''x'' is an integer, the real part of zeta is approximately {{nowrap|1 + 2<sup>−''s''</sup>}}, and the imaginary part is approximately zero; that is, zeta is approximately real. Starting from {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} +∞}} with ''x'' an integer, we can trace a line back towards the critical strip on which zeta is real. Since when {{nowrap|''s'' >> 1}} the derivative is approximately {{nowrap|−ln(2) / 2<sup>''s''</sup>}}, it is negative on this line of real values for zeta, meaning that the real value for zeta increases as ''s'' decreases. The zeta function approaches 1 uniformly as ''s'' increases to infinity, so as ''s'' decreases, the real-valued zeta function along this line of real values continues to increase though all real values from 1 to infinity monotonically. When it crosses the critical line where {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} {{frac|2}}}}, it produces a real value of zeta on the critical line. Points on the critical line where {{nowrap|ζ({{frac|2}} + i''g'')}} are real are called "Gram points", after [[Wikipedia:Jørgen Pedersen Gram|Jørgen Pedersen Gram]]. We thus have associated pure-octave edos, where ''x'' is an integer, to a value near to the pure octave, at the special sorts of Gram points which corresponds to edos. | As {{nowrap|''s'' > 1}} gets larger, the Dirichlet series for the zeta function is increasingly dominated by the 2 term, getting ever closer to simply {{nowrap|1 + 2<sup>−''z''</sup>}}, which approaches 1 as {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} Re(''z'')}} becomes larger. When {{nowrap|''s'' >> 1}} and ''x'' is an integer, the real part of zeta is approximately {{nowrap|1 + 2<sup>−''s''</sup>}}, and the imaginary part is approximately zero; that is, zeta is approximately real. Starting from {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} +∞}} with ''x'' an integer, we can trace a line back towards the critical strip on which zeta is real. Since when {{nowrap|''s'' >> 1}} the derivative is approximately {{nowrap|−ln(2) / 2<sup>''s''</sup>}}, it is negative on this line of real values for zeta, meaning that the real value for zeta increases as ''s'' decreases. The zeta function approaches 1 uniformly as ''s'' increases to infinity, so as ''s'' decreases, the real-valued zeta function along this line of real values continues to increase though all real values from 1 to infinity monotonically. When it crosses the critical line where {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} {{frac|2}}}}, it produces a real value of zeta on the critical line. Points on the critical line where {{nowrap|ζ({{frac|2}} + i''g'')}} are real are called "Gram points", after [[Wikipedia:Jørgen Pedersen Gram|Jørgen Pedersen Gram]]. We thus have associated pure-octave edos, where ''x'' is an integer, to a value near to the pure octave, at the special sorts of Gram points which corresponds to edos. | ||
| Line 94: | Line 94: | ||
Note that for one of its neighbors, 271, it isn't entirely clear which peak value corresponds to the line of real values from +∞. This can be determined by looking at the absolute value of zeta along other ''s'' values, such as {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} 1}} or {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} {{frac|3|4}}}}, and in this case the local minimum at 271.069 is the value in question. However, other peak values are not without their interest; the local maximum at 270.941, for instance, is associated to a different mapping for 3. | Note that for one of its neighbors, 271, it isn't entirely clear which peak value corresponds to the line of real values from +∞. This can be determined by looking at the absolute value of zeta along other ''s'' values, such as {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} 1}} or {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} {{frac|3|4}}}}, and in this case the local minimum at 271.069 is the value in question. However, other peak values are not without their interest; the local maximum at 270.941, for instance, is associated to a different mapping for 3. | ||
To generate this plot using the free version of Wolfram Cloud, you can run <code>Plot | To generate this plot using the free version of Wolfram Cloud, you can run <code>Plot[Abs[RiemannSiegelZ[9.06472028x]], {x, 11.9, 12.1}]</code> and then in the menu select '''Evaluation > Evaluate Cells'''. Change "'''11.9'''" and "'''12.1'''" to whatever values you want, e.g. to view the curve around 15edo you might use the values "'''14.9'''" and "'''15.1'''". | ||
You can also view the plot using [https://www.desmos.com/calculator/dstp7wnidf Zeta in Desmos]. | You can also view the plot using [https://www.desmos.com/calculator/dstp7wnidf Zeta in Desmos]. | ||