Deeptone: Difference between revisions

CompactStar (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
CompactStar (talk | contribs)
 
(10 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 14: Line 14:
'''Deeptone''', a.k.a. '''tragicomical''', is a [[5-limit]] [[regular temperament|temperament]] that [[tempering out|tempers out]] the [[comma]] [[177147/163840]]. It is generated by a fifth (~[[3/2]]), which is typically sharper than in [[7edo]] but flatter than in [[flattone]] or [[flattertone]] (approximately 686-691{{cent}}). The ~[[5/4]] is reached by eleven fifths octave-reduced, which is an augmented third (C–E♯). A characteristic feature of deeptone is that the [[81/80|syntonic comma]] is tuned negative, represented by a diminished unison (C–C♭). This means that ~[[81/64]] is a ''submajor third'', tuned flatter than ~[[5/4]], and ~[[32/27]] is a ''supraminor third'', tuned sharper than ~[[6/5]], and the sizes of [[9/8]] and [[10/9]] are essentially swapped. It is quite low-accuracy because of its very flat tuning of 3/2, and it is rated as high-[[badness]] by most badness metrics due to the combination of high [[error]] and high [[complexity]], but it is still a usable temperament. Four edos support deeptone in their [[patent val]] ([[7edo]], [[33edo]], [[40edo]], and [[47edo]]), and additionally there is the near-patent val [[54edo|54b-edo]].  
'''Deeptone''', a.k.a. '''tragicomical''', is a [[5-limit]] [[regular temperament|temperament]] that [[tempering out|tempers out]] the [[comma]] [[177147/163840]]. It is generated by a fifth (~[[3/2]]), which is typically sharper than in [[7edo]] but flatter than in [[flattone]] or [[flattertone]] (approximately 686-691{{cent}}). The ~[[5/4]] is reached by eleven fifths octave-reduced, which is an augmented third (C–E♯). A characteristic feature of deeptone is that the [[81/80|syntonic comma]] is tuned negative, represented by a diminished unison (C–C♭). This means that ~[[81/64]] is a ''submajor third'', tuned flatter than ~[[5/4]], and ~[[32/27]] is a ''supraminor third'', tuned sharper than ~[[6/5]], and the sizes of [[9/8]] and [[10/9]] are essentially swapped. It is quite low-accuracy because of its very flat tuning of 3/2, and it is rated as high-[[badness]] by most badness metrics due to the combination of high [[error]] and high [[complexity]], but it is still a usable temperament. Four edos support deeptone in their [[patent val]] ([[7edo]], [[33edo]], [[40edo]], and [[47edo]]), and additionally there is the near-patent val [[54edo|54b-edo]].  


It can be regarded as an unusual example of a [[cluster temperament]] with 7 clusters of notes in an octave. The chroma or "super-comma" in this case represents 80/81~[[2187/2048]] (in the 2.3.5.13 extension, 80/81~2187/2048~[[27/26]]~[[65/64]]).  It only has a single mapping of [[3/2]], but it might be seen as [[dual-fifth]], at least with flatter generators like in [[47edo]] and [[54edo|54b-edo]], where the "perfect fifth" becomes a flat fifth and "augmented fifth" becomes a sharp fifth (but if you use a sharper generator like in [[33edo]], the "perfect fifth" is clearly more accurate).
It can be regarded as an unusual example of a [[cluster temperament]] with 7 clusters of notes in an octave. The chroma or "super-comma" in this case represents 80/81~[[2187/2048]] (in the 2.3.5.13 extension, 80/81~[[512/507]]~[[65/64]]~[[27/26]]~2187/2048).  It only has a single mapping of [[3/2]], but it might be seen as [[dual-fifth]], at least with flatter generators like in [[47edo]] and [[54edo|54b-edo]], where the "perfect fifth" becomes a flat fifth and "augmented fifth" becomes a sharp fifth (but if you use a sharper generator like in [[33edo]], the "perfect fifth" is clearly more accurate).


The name ''deeptone'' was given by {{u|CompactStar}} in 2023, referring to the temperament featuring fifths even flatter than [[flattone]]. ''Tragicomical'' was allegedly given by [[groundfault]] no later than 2023.<ref>[https://en.xen.wiki/index.php?title=Talk:177147/163840&oldid=107105 Xenharmonic Wiki | Talk: 177147/163840]</ref>
The name ''deeptone'' was given by {{u|CompactStar}} in 2023, referring to the temperament featuring fifths even flatter than [[flattone]]. ''Tragicomical'' was allegedly given by [[groundfault]] no later than 2023.<ref>[https://en.xen.wiki/index.php?title=Talk:177147/163840&oldid=107105 Xenharmonic Wiki | Talk: 177147/163840]</ref>
Line 25: Line 25:


== Extensions ==
== Extensions ==
Deeptone has an accurate [[13/8]], represented by the interval notated as a minor sixth, so it is very plausible to have a 2.3.5.13-[[subgroup]] [[extension]] tempering out both [[2187/2080]] and [[1053/1024]] (the tridecimal quartertone). This also gives a more simple interpretation of deeptone's major and minor thirds as tridecimal neutral thirds [[16/13]] and [[39/32]] respectively. Tuning this deeptone extension in [[40edo]] results in essentially perfect tuning of [[13/8]] and [[16/13]], which is inherited from [[10edo]].
Deeptone has an accurate [[13/8]], represented by the interval notated as a minor sixth, so it is very plausible to have a 2.3.5.13-[[subgroup]] [[extension]] tempering out both [[2187/2080]] and [[1053/1024]] (the tridecimal quartertone). This also gives a more simple and accurate interpretation of deeptone's major and minor thirds as tridecimal neutral thirds [[16/13]] and [[39/32]] respectively. Tuning this deeptone extension in [[40edo]] results in essentially perfect tuning of [[13/8]] and [[16/13]], which is inherited from [[10edo]].


There are two possible ways to map [[7/4]], creating a 2.3.5.7.13 subgroup temperament, which are 7 & 40 (or 40 & 47) and 7d & 40 (or 33 & 40), but both are high in complexity. 7 & 40 maps 7/4 to the double-diminished seventh, while 7d & 40 maps it to the triple-augmented sixth.
There are two possible ways to map [[7/4]], creating a 2.3.5.7.13 subgroup temperament, which are 7 & 40 (or 40 & 47) and 7d & 40 (or 33 & 40), but both are high in complexity. 7 & 40 maps 7/4 to the double-diminished seventh, while 7d & 40 maps it to the triple-augmented sixth.
Line 54: Line 54:
| 6 || aug 4th || A4 || F{{sharp}} || 535.872 || [[729/512]], [[320/243]] || [[18/13]]
| 6 || aug 4th || A4 || F{{sharp}} || 535.872 || [[729/512]], [[320/243]] || [[18/13]]
|-
|-
| 7 || aug unison || A1 || C{{sharp}} || 25.184 || [[2187/2048]], [[81/80|80/81]] || [[27/26]], [[65/64]]
| 7 || aug unison || A1 || C{{sharp}} || 25.184 || [[2187/2048]], [[81/80|80/81]] || [[27/26]], [[65/64]], [[512/507]]
|-
|-
| 8 || aug 5th || A5 || G{{sharp}} || 714.496 || [[40/27]] ||
| 8 || aug 5th || A5 || G{{sharp}} || 714.496 || [[40/27]] ||
Line 68: Line 68:
| 13 || doubly-aug 4th || AA4 || F{{sharp2}} || 561.056 || [[45/32]] ||
| 13 || doubly-aug 4th || AA4 || F{{sharp2}} || 561.056 || [[45/32]] ||
|-
|-
| 14 || doubly-aug unison || AA1 || C{{sharp2}} || 50.368 || [[135/128]] ||
| 14 || doubly-aug unison || AA1 || C{{sharp2}} || 50.368 || [[135/128]] || [[40/39]], [[325/324]]
|-
|-
| 15 || doubly-aug 5th || AA5 || G{{sharp2}} || 739.680 || [[405/256]] || [[20/13]]
| 15 || doubly-aug 5th || AA5 || G{{sharp2}} || 739.680 || [[405/256]] || [[20/13]]
Line 74: Line 74:
| 16 || doubly-aug 2nd || AA2 || D{{sharp2}} || 228.992 || [[800/729]], [[1215/1024]] || [[15/13]]
| 16 || doubly-aug 2nd || AA2 || D{{sharp2}} || 228.992 || [[800/729]], [[1215/1024]] || [[15/13]]
|-
|-
| 17 || doubly-aug 6th || AA6 || A{{sharp2}} || 918.304 || [[400/243]] ||
| 17 || doubly-aug 6th || AA6 || A{{sharp2}} || 918.304 || [[400/243]] ||  
|-
|-
| 18 || doubly-aug 3rd || AA3 || E{{sharp2}} || 407.616 || [[100/81]] ||  
| 18 || doubly-aug 3rd || AA3 || E{{sharp2}} || 407.616 || [[100/81]] ||  
|-
|-
| 19 || doubly-aug 7th || AA7 || B{{sharp2}} || 1096.928 || [[50/27]] ||
| 19 || doubly-aug 7th || AA7 || B{{sharp2}} || 1096.928 || [[50/27]] ||
|-
| 20 || triply-aug 4th || AAA4 || F{{sharp}}{{sharp2}} || 586.240 || [[25/18]] ||
|-
| 21 || triply-aug unison || AAA1 || C{{sharp}}{{sharp2}} || 75.552 || [[25/24]] ||
|-
| 22 || triply-aug 5th || AAA5 || G{{sharp}}{{sharp2}} || 764.864 || [[25/16]] ||
|-
| 23 || triply-aug 2nd || AAA2 || D{{sharp}}{{sharp2}} || 254.176 || [[75/64]] ||
|-
| 24 || triply-aug 6th || AAA6 || A{{sharp}}{{sharp2}} || 976.538 || [[225/128]] ||
|-
| 25 || triply-aug 3rd || AAA3 || E{{sharp}}{{sharp2}} || 432.800 || [[675/512]] || [[50/39]]
|-
| 26 || triply-aug 7th || AAA7 || B{{sharp}}{{sharp2}} || 1122.112 || [[2025/1024]] || [[50/26]]
|}
|}
<nowiki/>* In 5-limit [[CWE]] tuning
<nowiki/>* In 5-limit [[CWE]] tuning
Line 97: Line 111:
| 685.714
| 685.714
| '''Lower bound of 5-odd-limit diamond monotone'''
| '''Lower bound of 5-odd-limit diamond monotone'''
|-
|
|
| 688.159
| [[Delta-rational]] [[4:5:6]] tuning
|-
|-
|  
|  
| [[6/5]]
| [[6/5]]
| 688.436
| 688.436
| 1/10-comma tuning
| 1/10-comma tuning, analogous to [[1/3-comma meantone]]
|-
|-
| [[61edo|35\61]]
| [[61edo|35\61]]
Line 112: Line 131:
| 688.889
| 688.889
| 54b val
| 54b val
|-
|
|
| 689.323
| Generator is 36<sup>1/9</sup><br>
True [[dual-fifth]] tuning where the "perfect 5th" and "augmented 5th" are equally good approximations of 3/2 and the "augmented 2nd" is an exact [[9/8]] (despite it ostensibly representing [[10/9]]). With the generator any flatter than this, the "augmented 5th" becomes a more accurate 3/2 than the "perfect 5th", which is why 47 is the last deeptone patent val.
|-
|-
| [[47edo|27\47]]
| [[47edo|27\47]]
Line 121: Line 146:
| [[5/4]]
| [[5/4]]
| 689.665
| 689.665
| 1/11-comma tuning
| 1/11-comma tuning, analogous to [[1/4-comma meantone]]
|-
|-
|  
|  
Line 137: Line 162:
| 690.000
| 690.000
|
|
|-
| [[73edo|42\73]]
|
| 690.411
| 73b val
|-
|-
|  
|  
Line 146: Line 176:
| [[15/8]]
| [[15/8]]
| 690.689
| 690.689
| 1/12-comma tuning
| 1/12-comma tuning, analogous to [[1/5-comma meantone]]
|-
|-
| [[33edo|19\33]]
| [[33edo|19\33]]
Line 160: Line 190:


== Music ==
== Music ==
* [https://youtu.be/scCuGXnj5IY ''Music in 33EDO (33-Tone Equal Temperament) - Feb 2024''] by [[Budjarn Lambeth]] (2024) (in 33edo diatonic, which can be seen as Deeptone[7] or [[Flattertone]][7])
* [https://youtu.be/scCuGXnj5IY ''Music in 33EDO (33-Tone Equal Temperament) - Feb 2024''] by [[Budjarn Lambeth]] (2024) (in 33edo diatonic, which can be interpreted as Deeptone[7] or [[Flattertone]][7])


== References ==
== References ==