Wolf interval: Difference between revisions

Added info about reason why or why not to use wolves
m typo
 
Line 5: Line 5:
# An interval which is technically not what it appears to be on the keyboard. In [[meantone12|meantone[12]]], there are four such major thirds – unless we expect septimal interpretations – in addition to the wolf fifth. This is an artifact in keyboard design and can be solved by adopting an isomorphic keyboard layout.  
# An interval which is technically not what it appears to be on the keyboard. In [[meantone12|meantone[12]]], there are four such major thirds – unless we expect septimal interpretations – in addition to the wolf fifth. This is an artifact in keyboard design and can be solved by adopting an isomorphic keyboard layout.  
# An interval which impresses the listener as [[discordance]], and/or sounds like an out-of-tune other interval, due to its sheer [[complexity]] and/or lack of proper harmonic context. For example, [[40/27]] is a wolf fifth that occurs in 5-limit just scales like [[zarlino]]. This is more often known as the ''impure'' or ''imperfect fifth''. Historically, it gave rise to the use of [[meantone]], which moderates its effect by distributing the [[syntonic comma]] among four fifths.  
# An interval which impresses the listener as [[discordance]], and/or sounds like an out-of-tune other interval, due to its sheer [[complexity]] and/or lack of proper harmonic context. For example, [[40/27]] is a wolf fifth that occurs in 5-limit just scales like [[zarlino]]. This is more often known as the ''impure'' or ''imperfect fifth''. Historically, it gave rise to the use of [[meantone]], which moderates its effect by distributing the [[syntonic comma]] among four fifths.  
It should be noted that wolf intervals are one of the core reasons theorists argue for tempering, and is therefore one of the so-called "pitfalls" of [[just intonation]]. When [[JI]] is used to produce a scale which aims to produce pure intervals, in many cases (besides JI scales derived from the [[Harmonic series|overtone]] or [[Subharmonic series|undertone]] series, along with a few other exceptions), it will be mathematically impossible for said scale to not include a collection of "impure" intervals which would be traditionally avoided. For instance, in Ptolemy's intense diatonic scale, it is impossible to remove from the scale [[27/16]], [[32/27]], [[27/20]], and [[40/27]] because it does not temper [[81/80]], which leaves intervals like 3/2, 5/4, etc. completely just. However, in some contexts the composer may want to intentionally include these intervals because of their "shimmering" effect as a result of their [[Beat|acousitic beating]] and/or harmonic context, along with many other possible reasons.
It should be noted that wolf intervals are one of the core reasons theorists argue for tempering, and is therefore one of the so-called "pitfalls" of [[just intonation]]. When [[JI]] is used to produce a scale which aims to produce pure intervals, in many cases (besides JI scales derived from the [[Harmonic series|overtone]] or [[Subharmonic series|undertone]] series, along with a few other exceptions), it will be mathematically impossible for said scale to not include a collection of "impure" intervals which would be traditionally avoided. For instance, in Ptolemy's intense diatonic scale, it is impossible to remove from the scale [[27/16]], [[32/27]], [[27/20]], and [[40/27]] because it does not temper [[81/80]], which leaves intervals like 3/2, 5/4, etc. completely just. However, in some contexts the composer may want to intentionally include these intervals because of their "shimmering" effect as a result of their [[Beat|acoustic beating]] and/or harmonic context, along with many other possible reasons.


== See also ==
== See also ==