3.5 subgroup: Difference between revisions

CompactStar (talk | contribs)
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit
CompactStar (talk | contribs)
 
(49 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
The 3.5 subgroup is a [[retraction]] of the [[5-limit]], obtained by removing prime 2. Its simplest [[expansion]] is the [[3.5.7 subgroup]], which adds prime [[7/1|7]].
The 3.5 subgroup is a [[retraction]] of the [[5-limit]], obtained by removing prime 2. Its simplest [[expansion]] is the [[3.5.7 subgroup]], which adds prime [[7/1|7]].


If used with [[3/1|tritave]]-equivalence, it is an infinite chain of stacking the classical major sixth [[5/3]] with tritave-reduction, analogous to how [[Pythagorean tuning]] (also known as the 2.3 subgroup or 3-limit) involves stacking [[2/1]] with octave-reduction. It can be regarded as an application of the [[Pythagorean tuning]] principle (stacking the smallest prime larger than the equave) to tritave-equivalence. The 3.5 subgroup is related to tritave-equivalent [[rank-2 temperament]]s generated by ~[[5/3]], such as 3.5.7 [[Arcturus]] and 3.5.11 [[Delta Centauri]]. The famous rank 2 Bohlen-Pierce/sensamagic temperament, however, is generated by [[7/3]].
If used with [[3/1|tritave]]-equivalence, it is an infinite chain of stacking the classical major sixth [[5/3]] with tritave-reduction, analogous to how [[Pythagorean tuning]] (also known as the 2.3 subgroup or 3-limit) involves stacking [[3/2]] with octave-reduction. It can be regarded as an application of the Pythagorean principle (stacking the smallest prime harmonic larger than the [[equave]]) to tritave-equivalence. The 3.5 subgroup is related to tritave-equivalent [[rank-2 temperament]]s generated by ~[[5/3]], such as 3.5.7 [[Arcturus]] and 3.5.11 [[Delta centauri]]. The famous rank 2 [[BPS]] temperament, however, is generated by [[7/3]].
 
== EDT approximation ==
[[EDT]]s which do relatively well at approximating 3.5 subgroup intervals can be found as the denominators of the convergents and semiconvergents of the {{w|continued fraction}} for the logarithm base 3 of 5. The sequence is equivalent to the numbers of notes per tritave in the [[mos scale]]s generated by a pure 3/1 period and pure 5/3 generator: {{EDTs| 2, 3, 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 15, 28, 43, 71, 114, 157, 200, 357, 514, 671, 828, 985  … }}


== MOS scales ==
== MOS scales ==
As it is a [[rank-2]] system, stacking 5/3 with tritave-reduction can produce [[MOS scale]]s, just like how Pythagorean famously produces one variation of pentatonic, diatonic and chromatic scales.
As it is a [[rank-2]] system, stacking 5/3 with tritave-reduction can produce [[MOS scale]]s, just like how Pythagorean tuning famously produces a version of the pentatonic, diatonic and chromatic scales.
 
The non-trivial MOS scales that are produced are: [[2L 1s (3/1-equivalent)|2L 1s<3/1>]], [[2L 3s (3/1-equivalent)|2L 3s<3/1>]], [[2L 5s (3/1-equivalent))|2L 5s<3/1>]], [[2L 7s (3/1-equivalent)|2L 7s<3/1>]], [[2L 9s (3/1-equivalent)|2L 9s<3/1>]], [[2L 11s (3/1-equivalent)|2L 11s<3/1>]], [[13L 2s (3/1-equivalent)|13L 2s<3/1>]], [[15L 13s (3/1-equivalent)|15L 13s<3/1>]], [[28L 15s (3/1-equivalent)|28L 15s<3/1>]], etc. Probably the most practical scales are the 11-note (2L 9s), 13-note (2L 11s), and 15-note (13L 2s) scales. The reason for all of the 2L scales is because 5/3 (884 cents) is quite near √3 (951 cents) (incidentally, this fact is realized by the [[bug]] temperament, and removing octaves from bug results in a 3.5 [[equal temperament]] interpretation of [[2edt]]). All of the scales with less than 11 notes are very hard (lopsided L/s ratio) due to the proximity to 2edt, making them difficult to use melodically, so it's more practical to use an 11-note or higher scale.
 
The 13-note MOS scale is also called [[Trithagorean]] by Jake Freivald (perhaps could be called Trithagorean[13] to specify, like saying Pythagorean[7] or Pythagorean[12]).
 
== Generator chain ==
<div style="display: inline-grid; margin-right: 25px;">
{|class="wikitable"
|-
!Number of generators
!Interval
!Cents
|-
|0
|[[1/1]]
|0.000
|-
|1
|[[5/3]]
|884.359
|-
|2
|[[25/9]]
|1768.717
|-
|3
|[[125/81]]
|751.121
|-
|4
|[[625/243]]
|1635.480
|-
|5
|[[3125/2187]]
|617.884
|-
|6
|[[15625/6561]]
|1502.242
|-
|7
|[[78125/59049]]
|484.646
|-
|8
|[[390625/177147]]
|1369.005
|-
|9
|[[1953125/1594323]]
|351.408
|-
|10
|[[9765625/4782969]]
|1235.767
|-
|11
|[[48828125/43046721]]
|218.171
|-
|12
|[[244140625/129140163]]
|1102.530
|-
|13
|[[1220703125/1162261467]]
|84.933
|-
|14
|[[6103515625/3486784401]]
|969.219
|-
|15
|[[30517578125/10460353203]]
|1853.651
|}
</div>
<div style="display: inline-grid; margin-right: 25px;">
{|class="wikitable"
|-
!Number of generators
!Interval
!Cents
|-
|0
|[[1/1]]
|0.000
|-
| -1
|[[9/5]]
|1017.596
|-
| -2
|[[27/25]]
|133.238
|-
| -3
|[[243/125]]
|1150.834
|-
| -4
|[[729/625]]
|266.475
|-
| -5
|[[6561/3125]]
|1284.071
|-
| -6
|[[19683/15625]]
|399.713
|-
| -7
|[[177147/78125]]
|1417.309
|-
| -8
|[[531441/390625]]
|532.950
|-
| -9
|[[4782969/1953125]]
|1550.547
|-
| -10
|[[14348907/9765625]]
|666.188
|-
| -11
|[[129140163/48828125]]
|1683.784
|-
| -12
|[[387420489/244140625]]
|799.425
|-
| -13
|[[3486784401/1220703125]]
|1817.021
|-
| -14
|[[10460353203/6103515625]]
|932.663
|-
| -15
|[[31381059609/30517578125]]
|48.304
|}
</div>
== Relationship with the full 5-limit ==
The common visualization of the full [[5-limit]] as a 2-dimensional lattice with 3 and 5 as generators can be seen as "3.5 subgroup with octave-equivalence". Every full 5-limit interval has an octave-equivalent [[AOV|all-odd voicing]] which is always contained in the 3.5 subgroup–for example [[5/4]] is not in the 3.5 subgroup, but its all-odd voicing [[5/1]] is.
 
 
[[Category:Just intonation subgroups|#]]
[[Category:Rank-2 temperaments|#]]
[[Category:5-limit|#]]