31edo: Difference between revisions

ArrowHead294 (talk | contribs)
mNo edit summary
m Fix typo
 
(11 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 13: Line 13:


== Theory ==
== Theory ==
31edo's [[3/2|perfect fifth]] is flat of just by 5.2{{c}}, as befits a tuning of [[meantone]]. The major third is less than a cent sharp of just [[5/4]], making it slightly sharp of [[quarter-comma meantone]]. 31edo's approximation of [[7/4]], a cent flat, is also very close to just. Because of the near-just 5/4 and 7/4, 31edo is relatively quite accurate in the [[7-limit]]. Many 7-limit JI scales are well-approximated in 31 (with tempering, of course).  
31edo's [[3/2|perfect fifth]] is flat of just by 5.2{{c}}, as befits a tuning of [[meantone]]. The major third is less than a cent sharp of just [[5/4]], making it slightly sharp of [[quarter-comma meantone]]. To get a better approximation to quarter-comma meantone requires going to much higher edo sizes: [[112edo]] (as 112b) to get a major third closer to just in absolute error, or [[174edo]] (as 174b) to get a major third closer to just in relative error. 31edo's approximation of [[7/4]], a cent flat, is also very close to just. Because of the near-just 5/4 and 7/4, 31edo is relatively quite accurate in the [[7-limit]]. Many 7-limit JI scales are well-approximated in 31 (with tempering, of course).  


Prime 11 is somewhat less accurate, making intervals like [[11/8]] off by about 9 cents. However, intervals like [[11/9]] and [[11/6]] are approximated quite well because the errors cancel out. This makes 31edo a very tone-efficient melodic approximation of the [[11-limit]] (and specifically the [[11-odd-limit]]), although it conflates [[9/7]] with [[14/11]] and [[11/8]] with [[15/11]]. It also maps most [[15-odd-limit]] intervals [[consistent]]ly, the exceptions being [[13/9]], [[13/11]], and their [[octave complement]]s.
Prime 11 is somewhat less accurate, making intervals like [[11/8]] off by about 9 cents. However, intervals like [[11/9]] and [[11/6]] are approximated quite well because the errors cancel out. For example, it closely approximates the pentad 11:12:15:18:21, where the largest error occurs in the [[6/5]] minor third. This makes 31edo a very efficient approximation of the [[11-limit]] (and specifically the [[11-odd-limit]]), although it conflates [[9/7]] with [[14/11]] and [[11/8]] with [[15/11]]. It also maps most [[15-odd-limit]] intervals [[consistent]]ly, the exceptions being [[13/9]], [[13/11]], and their [[octave complement]]s.


Other ways in which 31edo is especially accurate is that it represents a record in [[Pepper ambiguity]] in the [[7-odd-limit|7-]], [[9-odd-limit|9-]], and [[11-odd-limit]], which it is consistent through. It is also a [[strict zeta edo]], meaning that it is a zeta peak, zeta peak integer, zeta integral, and zeta gap edo all at once.
Other ways in which 31edo is especially accurate is that it represents a record in [[Pepper ambiguity]] in the [[7-odd-limit|7-]], [[9-odd-limit|9-]], and [[11-odd-limit]], which it is consistent through. It is also a [[strict zeta edo]], meaning that it is a zeta peak, zeta peak integer, zeta integral, and zeta gap edo all at once.
Line 58: Line 58:
! Interval categories
! Interval categories
! Approximate ratios<ref group="note">As a 13-limit temperament, with additional ratios of 17, 19, and 23. Inconsistent intervals are in ''italics''.</ref>
! Approximate ratios<ref group="note">As a 13-limit temperament, with additional ratios of 17, 19, and 23. Inconsistent intervals are in ''italics''.</ref>
! [[Kite's ups and downs notation|Ups and downs notation]]
! colspan="2" |[[Kite's ups and downs notation|Ups and downs notation]]
([[Enharmonic unisons in ups and downs notation|EUs]]: vvA1 and vd2)
|-
|-
| 0
| 0
Line 64: Line 65:
| Unison
| Unison
| [[1/1]]
| [[1/1]]
|P1
| {{UDnote|step=0}}
| {{UDnote|step=0}}
|-
|-
Line 70: Line 72:
| Super-unison
| Super-unison
| [[36/35]], [[45/44]], [[49/48]], [[50/49]], [[64/63]], [[128/125]]
| [[36/35]], [[45/44]], [[49/48]], [[50/49]], [[64/63]], [[128/125]]
|^1, d2
| {{UDnote|step=1}}
| {{UDnote|step=1}}
|-
|-
Line 76: Line 79:
| Subminor second
| Subminor second
| [[21/20]], [[22/21]], [[23/22]], [[25/24]], [[28/27]]
| [[21/20]], [[22/21]], [[23/22]], [[25/24]], [[28/27]]
|A1, vm2
| {{UDnote|step=2}}
| {{UDnote|step=2}}
|-
|-
Line 82: Line 86:
| Minor second
| Minor second
| [[14/13]], [[15/14]], [[16/15]]
| [[14/13]], [[15/14]], [[16/15]]
|m2
| {{UDnote|step=3}}
| {{UDnote|step=3}}
|-
|-
Line 88: Line 93:
| Neutral second
| Neutral second
| [[11/10]], [[12/11]], [[13/12]], [[35/32]]
| [[11/10]], [[12/11]], [[13/12]], [[35/32]]
|~2
| {{UDnote|step=4}}
| {{UDnote|step=4}}
|-
|-
Line 94: Line 100:
| Major second
| Major second
| [[9/8]], [[10/9]], [[19/17]], [[28/25]]
| [[9/8]], [[10/9]], [[19/17]], [[28/25]]
|M2
| {{UDnote|step=5}}
| {{UDnote|step=5}}
|-
|-
Line 100: Line 107:
| Supermajor second
| Supermajor second
| [[8/7]]
| [[8/7]]
|^M2
| {{UDnote|step=6}}
| {{UDnote|step=6}}
|-
|-
Line 106: Line 114:
| Subminor third
| Subminor third
| [[7/6]]
| [[7/6]]
|vm3
| {{UDnote|step=7}}
| {{UDnote|step=7}}
|-
|-
Line 112: Line 121:
| Minor third
| Minor third
| [[6/5]], [[25/21]], ''[[13/11]]''
| [[6/5]], [[25/21]], ''[[13/11]]''
|m3
| {{UDnote|step=8}}
| {{UDnote|step=8}}
|-
|-
Line 118: Line 128:
| Neutral third
| Neutral third
| [[11/9]], [[16/13]]
| [[11/9]], [[16/13]]
|~3
| {{UDnote|step=9}}
| {{UDnote|step=9}}
|-
|-
Line 124: Line 135:
| Major third
| Major third
| [[5/4]]
| [[5/4]]
|M3
| {{UDnote|step=10}}
| {{UDnote|step=10}}
|-
|-
Line 130: Line 142:
| Supermajor third
| Supermajor third
| [[9/7]], [[14/11]], [[23/18]], [[32/25]]
| [[9/7]], [[14/11]], [[23/18]], [[32/25]]
|^M3
| {{UDnote|step=11}}
| {{UDnote|step=11}}
|-
|-
Line 136: Line 149:
| Subfourth
| Subfourth
| [[13/10]], [[17/13]], [[21/16]]
| [[13/10]], [[17/13]], [[21/16]]
|v4
| {{UDnote|step=12}}
| {{UDnote|step=12}}
|-
|-
Line 142: Line 156:
| Perfect fourth
| Perfect fourth
| [[4/3]]
| [[4/3]]
|P4
| {{UDnote|step=13}}
| {{UDnote|step=13}}
|-
|-
Line 148: Line 163:
| Superfourth
| Superfourth
| [[11/8]], [[15/11]], [[26/19]], ''[[18/13]]'', [[48/35]]
| [[11/8]], [[15/11]], [[26/19]], ''[[18/13]]'', [[48/35]]
|^4, ~4
| {{UDnote|step=14}}
| {{UDnote|step=14}}
|-
|-
Line 154: Line 170:
| Augmented fourth
| Augmented fourth
| [[7/5]], [[25/18]], [[45/32]]
| [[7/5]], [[25/18]], [[45/32]]
|A4, vd5
| {{UDnote|step=15}}
| {{UDnote|step=15}}
|-
|-
Line 160: Line 177:
| Diminished fifth
| Diminished fifth
| [[10/7]], [[36/25]], [[64/45]]
| [[10/7]], [[36/25]], [[64/45]]
|^A4, d5
| {{UDnote|step=16}}
| {{UDnote|step=16}}
|-
|-
Line 166: Line 184:
| Subfifth
| Subfifth
| [[16/11]], [[19/13]], [[22/15]], ''[[13/9]]'', [[35/24]]
| [[16/11]], [[19/13]], [[22/15]], ''[[13/9]]'', [[35/24]]
|v5, ~5
| {{UDnote|step=17}}
| {{UDnote|step=17}}
|-
|-
Line 172: Line 191:
| Perfect fifth
| Perfect fifth
| [[3/2]]
| [[3/2]]
|P5
| {{UDnote|step=18}}
| {{UDnote|step=18}}
|-
|-
Line 178: Line 198:
| Superfifth
| Superfifth
| [[20/13]], [[26/17]], [[32/21]]
| [[20/13]], [[26/17]], [[32/21]]
|^5
| {{UDnote|step=19}}
| {{UDnote|step=19}}
|-
|-
Line 184: Line 205:
| Subminor sixth
| Subminor sixth
| [[11/7]], [[14/9]], [[25/16]]
| [[11/7]], [[14/9]], [[25/16]]
|vm6
| {{UDnote|step=20}}
| {{UDnote|step=20}}
|-
|-
Line 190: Line 212:
| Minor sixth
| Minor sixth
| [[8/5]]
| [[8/5]]
|m6
| {{UDnote|step=21}}
| {{UDnote|step=21}}
|-
|-
Line 196: Line 219:
| Neutral sixth
| Neutral sixth
| [[13/8]], [[18/11]]
| [[13/8]], [[18/11]]
|~6
| {{UDnote|step=22}}
| {{UDnote|step=22}}
|-
|-
Line 202: Line 226:
| Major sixth
| Major sixth
| [[5/3]], [[42/25]], ''[[22/13]]''
| [[5/3]], [[42/25]], ''[[22/13]]''
|M6
| {{UDnote|step=23}}
| {{UDnote|step=23}}
|-
|-
Line 208: Line 233:
| Supermajor sixth
| Supermajor sixth
| [[12/7]]
| [[12/7]]
|^M6
| {{UDnote|step=24}}
| {{UDnote|step=24}}
|-
|-
Line 214: Line 240:
| Subminor seventh
| Subminor seventh
| [[7/4]]
| [[7/4]]
|vm7
| {{UDnote|step=25}}
| {{UDnote|step=25}}
|-
|-
Line 220: Line 247:
| Minor seventh
| Minor seventh
| [[9/5]], [[16/9]], [[25/14]], [[34/19]]
| [[9/5]], [[16/9]], [[25/14]], [[34/19]]
|m7
| {{UDnote|step=26}}
| {{UDnote|step=26}}
|-
|-
Line 226: Line 254:
| Neutral seventh
| Neutral seventh
| [[11/6]], [[20/11]], [[24/13]], [[64/35]]
| [[11/6]], [[20/11]], [[24/13]], [[64/35]]
|~7
| {{UDnote|step=27}}
| {{UDnote|step=27}}
|-
|-
Line 232: Line 261:
| Major seventh
| Major seventh
| [[13/7]], [[15/8]], [[28/15]]
| [[13/7]], [[15/8]], [[28/15]]
|M7
| {{UDnote|step=28}}
| {{UDnote|step=28}}
|-
|-
Line 238: Line 268:
| Supermajor seventh
| Supermajor seventh
| [[21/11]], [[27/14]], [[40/21]], [[44/23]], [[48/25]]
| [[21/11]], [[27/14]], [[40/21]], [[44/23]], [[48/25]]
|^M7
| {{UDnote|step=29}}
| {{UDnote|step=29}}
|-
|-
Line 244: Line 275:
| Sub-octave
| Sub-octave
| [[35/18]], [[49/25]], [[63/32]], [[88/45]], [[96/49]], [[125/64]]
| [[35/18]], [[49/25]], [[63/32]], [[88/45]], [[96/49]], [[125/64]]
|v8
| {{UDnote|step=30}}
| {{UDnote|step=30}}
|-
|-
Line 250: Line 282:
| Octave
| Octave
| [[2/1]]
| [[2/1]]
|P8
| {{UDnote|step=31}}
| {{UDnote|step=31}}
|}
|}
Line 902: Line 935:
|-
|-
| 2.3
| 2.3
| {{monzo| -49 31 }}
| {{Monzo| -49 31 }}
| {{mapping| 31 49 }}
| {{Mapping| 31 49 }}
| +1.637
| +1.637
| 1.637
| 1.637
Line 910: Line 943:
| 2.3.5
| 2.3.5
| 81/80, 393216/390625
| 81/80, 393216/390625
| {{mapping| 31 49 72 }}
| {{Mapping| 31 49 72 }}
| +0.976
| +0.976
| 1.628
| 1.628
Line 917: Line 950:
| 2.3.5.7
| 2.3.5.7
| 81/80, 126/125, 1029/1024
| 81/80, 126/125, 1029/1024
| {{mapping| 31 49 72 87 }}
| {{Mapping| 31 49 72 87 }}
| +0.828
| +0.828
| 1.432
| 1.432
Line 924: Line 957:
| 2.3.5.7.11
| 2.3.5.7.11
| 81/80, 99/98, 121/120, 126/125
| 81/80, 99/98, 121/120, 126/125
| {{mapping| 31 49 72 87 107 }}
| {{Mapping| 31 49 72 87 107 }}
| +1.205
| +1.205
| 1.487
| 1.487
| 3.841
| 3.841
|-
|-
| 2.3.5.7.11.23
| 81/80, 99/98, 126/125, 161/160, 231/230
| {{Mapping| 31 49 72 87 107 140 }}
| +1.333
| 1.387
| 3.584
|- style="border-top: double;"
| 2.3.5.7.11.13
| 2.3.5.7.11.13
| 66/65, 81/80, 99/98, 105/104, 121/120
| 66/65, 81/80, 99/98, 105/104, 121/120
| {{mapping| 31 49 72 87 107 115 }}
| {{Mapping| 31 49 72 87 107 115 }}
| +0.502
| +0.502
| 2.072
| 2.072
| 5.353
| 5.353
|- style="border-top: double;"
| 2.3.5.7.11.23
| 81/80, 99/98, 126/125, 161/160, 231/230
| {{mapping| 31 49 72 87 107 140 }}
| +1.333
| 1.387
| 3.584
|}
|}
* 31et is lower in relative error than any previous equal temperaments in the 7-, 11-, 13-, and 17-limit. The next equal temperaments doing better in those subgroups are [[72edo|72]], 72, [[41edo|41]], and [[46edo|46]], respectively.
* 31et is lower in relative error than any previous equal temperaments in the 7-, 11-, 13-, and 17-limit. The next equal temperaments doing better in those subgroups are [[72edo|72]], 72, [[41edo|41]], and [[46edo|46]], respectively.
Line 1,242: Line 1,275:
* [[Syntonic–31 equivalence continuum]]
* [[Syntonic–31 equivalence continuum]]


31edo provides the [[optimal patent val]] for the rank-5 temperament tempering out the 13-limit comma [[66/65]], which equates [[6/5]] and [[13/11]]. It also provides the optimal patent val for mohajira, [[squares]], and [[casablanca]] in the 11-limit, and [[huygens|huygens/meantone]], squares, [[winston]], [[lupercalia]], and [[nightengale]] in the 13-limit.  
31edo provides the [[optimal patent val]] for the rank-5 temperament tempering out the 13-limit comma [[66/65]], which equates [[6/5]] and [[13/11]]. It also provides the optimal patent val for mohajira, [[squares]], and [[casablanca]] in the 11-limit, and [[huygens|huygens/meantone]], squares, [[winston]], [[lupercalia]], and [[nightingale]] in the 13-limit.  


{| class="wikitable center-1"
{| class="wikitable center-1"
Line 1,256: Line 1,289:
| 38.71
| 38.71
|  
|  
| [[Slender]]
| [[Diesic]] / [[slender]]
| (P8, P4/13)
| (P8, P4/13)
|-
|-
Line 1,262: Line 1,295:
| 77.42
| 77.42
| [[1L&nbsp;14s]], [[15L&nbsp;1s]]
| [[1L&nbsp;14s]], [[15L&nbsp;1s]]
| [[Valentine]] / [[lupercalia]]
| [[Valentine]] / [[valentino]] / [[lupercalia]]
| (P8, P5/9)
| (P8, P5/9)
|-
|-
Line 1,268: Line 1,301:
| 116.13
| 116.13
| [[1L&nbsp;9s]], [[10L&nbsp;1s]], [[10L&nbsp;11s]]
| [[1L&nbsp;9s]], [[10L&nbsp;1s]], [[10L&nbsp;11s]]
| [[Mercy]] / [[miracle]]
| [[Miracle]]
| (P8, P5/6)
| (P8, P5/6)
|-
|-
Line 1,274: Line 1,307:
| 154.84
| 154.84
| [[1L&nbsp;6s]], [[7L&nbsp;1s]], <br>[[8L&nbsp;7s]], [[8L&nbsp;15s]]
| [[1L&nbsp;6s]], [[7L&nbsp;1s]], <br>[[8L&nbsp;7s]], [[8L&nbsp;15s]]
| [[Greeley]] / [[nusecond]]
| [[Nusecond]]
| (P8, P11/11)
| (P8, P11/11)
|-
|-
Line 1,280: Line 1,313:
| 193.55
| 193.55
| [[1L&nbsp;5s]], [[6L&nbsp;1s]], [[6L&nbsp;7s]], <br>[[6L&nbsp;13s]], [[6L&nbsp;19s]]
| [[1L&nbsp;5s]], [[6L&nbsp;1s]], [[6L&nbsp;7s]], <br>[[6L&nbsp;13s]], [[6L&nbsp;19s]]
| [[Luna]] / [[didacus]] / [[hemithirds]] /<br>[[hemiwürschmidt]] / [[tutone]]
| [[Luna]], [[didacus]] / [[hemithirds]] /<br>[[hemiwürschmidt]] / [[tutone]]
| (P8, ccP4/15)
| (P8, ccP4/15)
|-
|-
Line 1,286: Line 1,319:
| 232.26
| 232.26
| [[1L&nbsp;4s]], [[5L&nbsp;1s]], [[5L&nbsp;6s]], <br>[[5L&nbsp;11s]], [[5L&nbsp;16s]], [[5L&nbsp;21s]]
| [[1L&nbsp;4s]], [[5L&nbsp;1s]], [[5L&nbsp;6s]], <br>[[5L&nbsp;11s]], [[5L&nbsp;16s]], [[5L&nbsp;21s]]
| [[Mothra]] / [[mosura]]<br>[[Quadrawell]]
| [[Mothra]] / [[mosura]]<br>[[Oncle]]
| (P8, P5/3)
| (P8, P5/3)
|-
|-
Line 1,292: Line 1,325:
| 270.97
| 270.97
| [[1L&nbsp;3s]], [[4L&nbsp;1s]], [[4L&nbsp;5s]], <br>[[9L&nbsp;4s]], [[9L&nbsp;13s]]
| [[1L&nbsp;3s]], [[4L&nbsp;1s]], [[4L&nbsp;5s]], <br>[[9L&nbsp;4s]], [[9L&nbsp;13s]]
| [[Orson]] / [[orwell]] / [[winston]]
| [[Orwell]] / [[winston]]
| (P8, P12/7)
| (P8, P12/7)
|-
|-
Line 1,298: Line 1,331:
| 309.68
| 309.68
| [[3L&nbsp;1s]], [[4L&nbsp;3s]], [[4L&nbsp;7s]], <br>[[4L&nbsp;11s]], [[4L&nbsp;15s]], [[4L&nbsp;19s]], <br>[[4L&nbsp;23s]]
| [[3L&nbsp;1s]], [[4L&nbsp;3s]], [[4L&nbsp;7s]], <br>[[4L&nbsp;11s]], [[4L&nbsp;15s]], [[4L&nbsp;19s]], <br>[[4L&nbsp;23s]]
| [[Myna]]<br>[[Triwell]]
| [[Myna]]
| (P8, ccP5/10)
| (P8, ccP5/10)
|-
|-
Line 1,310: Line 1,343:
| 387.10
| 387.10
| [[3L&nbsp;1s]], [[3L&nbsp;4s]], [[3L&nbsp;7s]], <br>[[3L&nbsp;10s]], [[3L&nbsp;13s]], [[3L&nbsp;16s]], <br>[[3L&nbsp;19s]], [[3L&nbsp;22s]], [[3L&nbsp;25s]]
| [[3L&nbsp;1s]], [[3L&nbsp;4s]], [[3L&nbsp;7s]], <br>[[3L&nbsp;10s]], [[3L&nbsp;13s]], [[3L&nbsp;16s]], <br>[[3L&nbsp;19s]], [[3L&nbsp;22s]], [[3L&nbsp;25s]]
| [[Würschmidt]] / [[worschmidt]]
| [[Würschmidt]] / [[worschmidt]]<br>[[Grendel]]
| (P8, ccP5/8)
| (P8, ccP5/8)
|-
|-
Line 1,334: Line 1,367:
| 541.94
| 541.94
| [[2L&nbsp;3s]], [[2L&nbsp;5s]], [[2L&nbsp;7s]], <br>[[9L&nbsp;2s]], [[11L&nbsp;9s]]
| [[2L&nbsp;3s]], [[2L&nbsp;5s]], [[2L&nbsp;7s]], <br>[[9L&nbsp;2s]], [[11L&nbsp;9s]]
| [[Casablanca]]<br>[[Cypress]]<br>[[Oracle]]
| [[Casablanca]]<br>[[Cypress]] / [[necromanteion]]<br>[[Oracle]]
| (P8, c<sup>5</sup>P4/12)
| (P8, c<sup>5</sup>P4/12)
|-
|-
Line 1,343: Line 1,376:
| (P8, ccP4/5)
| (P8, ccP4/5)
|}
|}
<nowiki/>* [[Normal forms #Equave-reduced-generator form|Octave-reduced form]], reduced to the first half-octave, and [[normal forms #Minimal-generator form|minimal form]] in parentheses if distinct
<nowiki/>* In [[normal forms #Minimal-generator form|minimal-generator form]]
 
31edo can additionally be detemepered to [[borwell]] (31 & 106), [[countermiracle]] (31 & 145), [[triwell]] (31 & 159), [[quadrawell]] (31 & 212), [[birds]] (31 & 217), [[rainwell]] (31 & 265), and [[quasiorwell]] (31 & 270).


== Octave stretch or compression ==
== Octave stretch or compression ==
Line 1,437: Line 1,472:


* 17 is sharp, like 13. In fact, the 17:13 ratio is matched within a tenth of a cent.
* 17 is sharp, like 13. In fact, the 17:13 ratio is matched within a tenth of a cent.
* 19 is also sharp, like 13 and 17. The 19:17 ratio is about one cent sharp. 31edo could be considered a tuning of the 2.5.7.13.17.19 subgroup, on which it is consistent (see [[Quince clan#Mercy|mercy temperament]]).
* 19 is also sharp, like 13 and 17. The 19:17 ratio is about one cent sharp. 31edo could be considered a tuning of the 2.5.7.13.17.19 subgroup, on which it is consistent (see [[mercy]] temperament).
* 23 is about as flat as 11. The chromatic semitone is about half a cent off from 23:22. 31edo could be considered a tuning of the 2.3.5.7.11.23 subgroup, on which it is consistent.
* 23 is about as flat as 11. The chromatic semitone is about half a cent off from 23:22. 31edo could be considered a tuning of the 2.3.5.7.11.23 subgroup, on which it is consistent.
* 27 is quite flat, as it's 3<sup>3</sup> and the error from the meantone fifths accumulates.
* 27 is quite flat, as it's 3<sup>3</sup> and the error from the meantone fifths accumulates.