User:Hkm/Sandbox: Difference between revisions

Hkm (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Hkm (talk | contribs)
No edit summary
Tags: Visual edit Mobile edit Mobile web edit Advanced mobile edit
 
(37 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
== List of very bad pages (Sadbox) ==
{{Editable user page}}


=== Overly mathematical ===
== Sadbox ==
[[Wedgies and multivals]]


[[Tenney–Euclidean]]
=== Impractical ===
3 Wedgies


[[Otonality and utonality]]
5 TE


=== Terribly written ===
5 Otonality and utonality (what are the musical implications?)
[[Intro to Xenharmonics]] (can be supplemented with user:hkm/Intro_page)
 
2 Balanced word
 
2 43ed2
 
3 31ed2 (beginner-friendliness)
 
=== Badly written ===
5 Intro to Xenharmonics (can be supplemented with user:hkm/Intro_page)
 
4 Concordance
 
2 29ed2 (needs a clearer focus on essentially tempered chords in the 2.3.7/5.11/5.13/5 subgroup, less focus on temperaments of 29edo, and less trivia)
 
4 Periodicity block
 
3 FAQ


=== Unnecessary ===
=== Unnecessary ===
[[Oodako]]
1 Oodako
 
1 Trug
 
1 Oviminor
 
2 A bunch of stub pages
 
=== Badly named ===
1 1025/1024


[[Augmented_family#Trug]]
=== Badly designed ===
2 Ploidacot (why the number names?)


All edt pages above 131
=== Badly formatted ===
2 Practically all edo pages <50 (algorithmically generated material, like GPVs and sagittal notations, should be moved to the GPV and sagittal pages, for example. The interval table gets to stay though)


All edf pages above 12
== Badness ==
{| class="wikitable sortable" style="text-align: right;"
|+ Temperament Rankings
! style="width: 25%;" | EDO
! style="width: 25%;" | GPV
! style="width: 25%;" | Goodness
! style="width: 25%;" | Octave stretch
|-
| 1 || 0.91 || 11.8 ||  +0.00
|-
| 2 || 1.88 || 12.4 ||  +0.05
|-
| 3 || 2.91 || 14.2 ||  -5.13
|-
| 4 || 3.97 || 13.2 ||  -0.01
|-
| 5 || 5.12 || 14.8 ||  -0.00
|-
| 6 || 6.00 || 14.3 ||  -0.22
|-
| 7 || 6.91 || 16.7 ||  -0.31
|-
| 8 || 8.03 || 16.2 ||  -18.36
|-
| 9 || 9.03 || 18.0 ||  -0.12
|-
| 10 || 10.03 || 20.1 ||  +0.27
|-
| 11 || 11.00 || 16.2 ||  -2.52
|-
| 12 || 12.03 || 27.2 ||  -0.01
|-
| 13 || 12.88 || 17.9 ||  +0.43
|-
| 14 || 13.91 || 24.3 ||  +9.75
|-
| 15 || 15.06 || 26.4 ||  -4.16
|-
| 16 || 15.91 || 24.0 ||  +0.14
|-
| 17 || 17.06 || 28.7 ||  -2.47
|-
| 18 || 18.12 || 23.2 ||  -8.80
|-
| 19 || 19.03 || 32.8 ||  +3.38
|-
| 20 || 19.97 || 22.5 ||  +1.02
|-
| 21 || 20.97 || 26.5 ||  -0.73
|-
| 22 || 22.09 || 34.0 ||  -1.50
|-
| 23 || 22.88 || 25.2 ||  +8.60
|-
| 24 || 24.00 || 33.9 ||  +0.03
|-
| 25 || 25.03 || 26.0 ||  +0.69
|-
| 26 || 25.94 || 34.4 ||  +2.77
|-
| 27 || 27.12 || 36.2 ||  -4.24
|-
| 28 || 27.88 || 27.4 ||  +7.01
|-
| 29 || 28.94 || 35.5 ||  +3.21
|-
| 30 || 30.06 || 27.5 ||  -2.51
|-
| 31 || 31.00 || 40.2 ||  +0.33
|-
| 32 || 32.03 || 31.8 ||  -2.37
|-
| 33 || 32.88 || 29.6 ||  +4.40
|-
| 34 || 34.03 || 39.6 ||  -1.75
|-
| 35 || 34.94 || 32.0 ||  +2.81
|-
| 36 || 36.03 || 37.3 ||  +0.29
|-
| 37 || 37.06 || 35.9 ||  -1.00
|-
| 38 || 37.88 || 38.1 ||  +3.88
|-
| 39 || 39.06 || 38.3 ||  -3.89
|-
| 40 || 39.94 || 33.6 ||  +1.23
|-
| 41 || 41.00 || 42.7 ||  +0.14
|-
| 42 || 42.12 || 34.4 ||  -4.29
|-
| 43 || 43.09 || 39.9 ||  -1.04
|-
| 44 || 44.00 || 36.5 ||  -0.76
|-
| 45 || 44.88 || 38.4 ||  +4.01
|-
| 46 || 46.00 || 42.9 ||  +0.14
|-
| 47 || 46.91 || 33.3 ||  +1.42
|-
| 48 || 47.97 || 38.4 ||  +0.35
|-
| 49 || 49.12 || 40.1 ||  -3.48
|-
| 50 || 49.94 || 41.6 ||  +1.41
|-
| 51 || 51.06 || 37.5 ||  -2.05
|-
| 52 || 51.91 || 34.1 ||  +0.50
|-
| 53 || 53.00 || 44.1 ||  +0.08
|-
| 54 || 54.06 || 36.9 ||  -2.68
|-
| 55 || 54.88 || 38.6 ||  +2.81
|-
| 56 || 55.94 || 40.8 ||  -0.07
|-
| 57 || 56.94 || 39.3 ||  +0.72
|-
| 58 || 58.09 || 43.5 ||  -1.55
|-
| 59 || 59.09 || 35.6 ||  -1.95
|-
| 60 || 59.97 || 42.6 ||  +1.54
|-
| 61 || 61.12 || 38.5 ||  -2.54
|-
| 62 || 61.97 || 42.0 ||  +1.42
|-
| 63 || 63.03 || 42.2 ||  -0.33
|-
| 64 || 63.88 || 38.8 ||  +3.49
|-
| 65 || 65.06 || 43.2 ||  -0.56
|-
| 66 || 66.12 || 37.8 ||  -3.38
|-
| 67 || 67.09 || 40.0 ||  -0.37
|-
| 68 || 68.06 || 43.4 ||  -0.79
|-
| 69 || 68.91 || 39.5 ||  +1.86
|-
| 70 || 70.09 || 40.6 ||  -0.63
|-
| 71 || 71.12 || 38.6 ||  -2.08
|-
| 72 || 71.97 || 45.0 ||  +0.71
|-
| 73 || 73.12 || 40.6 ||  -2.32
|-
| 74 || 74.00 || 40.1 ||  -0.00
|-
| 75 || 75.09 || 41.7 ||  -1.46
|-
| 76 || 75.88 || 39.4 ||  +2.03
|-
| 77 || 76.97 || 44.0 ||  +0.21
|-
| 78 || 78.09 || 40.8 ||  -0.80
|-
| 79 || 78.91 || 41.3 ||  +1.19
|-
| 80 || 80.09 || 43.9 ||  -1.02
|-
| 81 || 80.88 || 41.2 ||  +1.28
|-
| 82 || 82.00 || 42.3 ||  +0.57
|-
| 83 || 83.12 || 39.3 ||  -2.12
|-
| 84 || 84.03 || 43.6 ||  -0.05
|-
| 85 || 85.12 || 40.8 ||  -1.89
|-
| 86 || 85.88 || 41.2 ||  +1.99
|-
| 87 || 87.00 || 44.3 ||  -0.26
|-
| 88 || 87.91 || 40.2 ||  +1.70
|-
| 89 || 89.03 || 43.2 ||  -0.33
|-
| 90 || 90.06 || 41.2 ||  -1.07
|-
| 91 || 90.88 || 42.6 ||  +1.97
|-
| 92 || 92.00 || 42.0 ||  +0.00
|-
| 93 || 92.88 || 40.9 ||  +0.86
|-
| 94 || 94.03 || 44.3 ||  +0.15
|-
| 95 || 95.09 || 42.1 ||  -1.55
|-
| 96 || 95.94 || 43.0 ||  +0.65
|-
| 97 || 97.00 || 40.9 ||  -0.03
|-
| 98 || 97.91 || 41.5 ||  +1.25
|-
| 99 || 99.06 || 44.2 ||  -0.71
|-
| 100 || 99.91 || 41.2 ||  +1.41
|-
| 101 || 100.91 || 42.0 ||  +1.52
|-
| 102 || 102.09 || 42.1 ||  -1.33
|-
| 103 || 102.94 || 44.2 ||  +0.75
|-
| 104 || 104.06 || 42.9 ||  -0.73
|-
| 105 || 104.94 || 40.1 ||  +0.39
|-
| 106 || 106.00 || 43.1 ||  +0.09
|-
| 107 || 107.12 || 40.9 ||  -1.88
|-
| 108 || 108.00 || 42.1 ||  -0.13
|-
| 109 || 109.03 || 43.0 ||  -0.03
|-
| 110 || 109.88 || 41.5 ||  +1.48
|-
| 111 || 111.00 || 44.1 ||  -0.61
|-
| 112 || 111.91 || 41.1 ||  +1.43
|-
| 113 || 112.97 || 43.8 ||  +0.39
|-
| 114 || 114.12 || 42.4 ||  -0.88
|-
| 115 || 114.97 || 42.3 ||  +0.28
|-
| 116 || 116.09 || 42.1 ||  -1.34
|-
| 117 || 116.88 || 40.5 ||  +1.62
|-
| 118 || 117.97 || 44.3 ||  +0.20
|-
| 119 || 119.12 || 40.7 ||  -1.35
|-
| 120 || 120.09 || 42.5 ||  -0.19
|-
| 121 || 121.09 || 44.1 ||  -0.74
|-
| 122 || 121.91 || 42.6 ||  +1.17
|-
| 123 || 123.09 || 42.2 ||  -0.88
|-
| 124 || 124.12 || 41.4 ||  -0.39
|-
| 125 || 124.94 || 43.8 ||  +0.54
|-
| 126 || 126.12 || 42.4 ||  -1.35
|-
| 127 || 126.91 || 42.2 ||  +0.62
|-
| 128 || 127.97 || 43.0 ||  -0.03
|-
| 129 || 128.91 || 41.4 ||  +0.94
|-
| 130 || 130.00 || 44.2 ||  -0.00
|-
| 131 || 131.03 || 41.7 ||  -0.59
|-
| 132 || 131.94 || 42.9 ||  +1.23
|-
| 133 || 133.06 || 42.9 ||  -0.50
|-
| 134 || 133.91 || 42.4 ||  +0.73
|-
| 135 || 135.12 || 42.9 ||  -0.39
|-
| 136 || 136.12 || 42.1 ||  -0.97
|-
| 137 || 137.03 || 43.5 ||  -0.06
|-
| 138 || 138.09 || 42.4 ||  -1.25
|-
| 139 || 139.00 || 41.9 ||  +0.31
|-
| 140 || 139.97 || 43.9 ||  +0.12
|}
== 128::256 ==