Eigenmonzo: Difference between revisions

Cmloegcmluin (talk | contribs)
→With respect to the projection matrix: better if this point comes first, so the points in the next paragraph are less confusing
Overthink (talk | contribs)
m more correct
 
(7 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
An '''eigenmonzo''' (also known as an '''unchanged interval''') is a (usually justly intoned) interval that remains unchanged when a specific tuning of a given temperament is applied to it.
An '''eigenmonzo''' (also known as an '''unchanged interval''') is a (usually justly intoned) interval that remains unchanged when a specific tuning of a given temperament is applied to it. The term "eigenmonzo" does not imply that the interval is notated in monzo form, so that if 2.3 {{Monzo|2 -1}} is an eigenmonzo, then we may also refer to the same interval written as a ratio, 4/3, as an eigenmonzo.


A [[regular temperament]] transforms untempered intervals into tempered intervals, which changes most of their sizes. Only a small set of exceptional intervals do not change in size. This set of unchanged intervals depends on the choice of tuning.  
A [[regular temperament]] transforms untempered intervals into tempered intervals, which changes most of their sizes. Only a small set of exceptional intervals do not change in size. This set of unchanged intervals depends on the choice of tuning.  


A popular example of an eigenmonzo is the JI interval {{monzo| 0 0 1 }}, or 1:5, when it is mapped by [[quarter-comma meantone]]; because this temperament tuning's generator is defined as exactly one-quarter the size of the interval 1:5, it remains justly tuned.
A popular example of an unchanged interval is the JI interval 5/1, when it is mapped by [[quarter-comma meantone]]; because this temperament tuning's generator is defined as exactly one-quarter the size of the interval 5/1, it remains justly tuned.


For any pure-octave temperament tuning, {{monzo| 1 }}, aka 1:2, is an eigenmonzo.
For any pure-octave temperament tuning, 2/1 is an unchanged interval.


A [[rank]]-''n'' temperament can have up to ''n'' different eigenmonzos — one for each [[generator]].
A [[rank]]-''n'' temperament can have up to ''n'' linearly independent unchanged intervals—one for each [[generator]].


== With respect to the projection matrix ==
The term "eigenmonzo" here comes from the [[linear algebra formalism]], where intervals are often represented as vectors corresponding to their [[monzos]] (and thus instances of "vector" are often replaced with "monzo"). An [[wikipedia: Eigenvalues and eigenvectors|eigenvector]] is a vector that is not rotated (only scaled) by a matrix.  The etymology of "eigen" is "own" in the sense of "characteristic"; the set of unrotated vectors and their scale factors are considered to characterize the transformation represented by the matrix. In this case, the transformation matrix is the [[projection]] corresponding to the tuning of the regular temperament, which gives the conflations of the just bases with [[Radical interval|radical intervals]], such as 3/2 to 5^(1/4). Note that this is ''not'' the matrix corresponding to the [[mapping]], which cannot specify a precise tuning.


The "monzo" part of "eigenmonzo" should not be taken to imply that the interval is notated in monzo form. For example, if {{monzo| 2 -1 }} is an eigenmonzo, then we may also refer to this same interval expressed in quotient form, 4/3, as an eigenmonzo.
However, the definition of eigenmonzo is more precise; along with corresponding to an eigenvector, it must be scaled by a factor of 1 (i.e. left unchanged). In other words, there are many intervals that correspond to eigenvectors of a projection but that are not unchanged intervals in the corresponding tuning (most notably, any comma tempered out by a temperament is scaled to 0, but that is obviously not unchanged).
 
The "eigen" part of the term "eigenmonzo" comes from the fact that these intervals are [[wikipedia: Eigenvalues and eigenvectors|eigenvectors]] (vectors that are not rotated, only scaled) of the tuning's [[projection matrix]] (not the [[mapping|temperament's mapping matrix]]). The etymology of "eigen" is "own" in the sense of "characteristic"; the set of unrotated vectors and their scale factors are considered to characterize the transformation represented by the matrix. However, only eigenvectors of the projection matrix with [[wikipedia: Eigenvalues and eigenvectors|eigenvalues]] (scale factors) equal to 1 (scaled by 1, i.e. unchanged) are considered to be eigenmonzos, while those with eigenvalue equal to 0 — which are the vanishing commas of the temperament, being that they are scaled by 0 — are ''not'' considered to be eigenmonzos. In other words, some things that are both monzos and eigenvectors are not eigenmonzos, most notably any vanishing comma of any temperament.


== See also ==
== See also ==
* [[Fractional monzo]]: for more mathematical information
* [[Eigenmonzo subgroup]]
* [[Eigenmonzo subgroup]]