User:Nick Vuci/TonalityDiamond: Difference between revisions

(15 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)

Line 1:

~~WORK~~-IN-~~PROGRESS AS OF 10MAY2025~~

Moved to [[Tonality diamond|main space]] 11 MAY 2025 by [[User:Sintel|Sintel]]

A '''tonality diamond''' is a symmetric organization of [[Otonality and utonality|otonal and utonal]] chords based around a central note and bounded by an [[Odd limit|odd-limit]]. First formalized in the [[7-odd-limit]] by [[wikipedia:Max_Friedrich_Meyer|Max F. Meyer]] in 1929, the idea became central to the music and theories of [[Harry Partch]], who built his tonal system around the [[11-odd-limit]] tonality diamond. Tonality diamonds have been used both conceptually (such as for [[Target tuning|targets]] of [[temperaments]]) and practically (such as for instrument layouts) in xenharmonics ever since.

[https://nickvuci.github.io/wiki-applets/tonalityDiamond.html ~~'''~~Play ~~some~~ tonality diamonds ~~to hear how they sound~~.''']

'''[https://nickvuci.github.io/wiki-applets/TonalityDiamond/tonalityDiamond.html Play with tonality diamonds in your browser here.]'''

== Construction ==

File:How to tonality diamond 1.png|'''Step 1: Take the numbers of an odd-limit and arrange them along two axes.'''

File:How to tonality diamond 2.png|'''Step 2: Using one ~~row~~ as the numerator and the other as the denominator, fill in the cells with the ratios they form.'''

File:How to tonality diamond 2.png|'''Step 2: Using one axis as the numerator and the other as the denominator, fill in the cells with the ratios they form.'''

File:How to tonality diamond 3.png|'''Step 3: Octave-reduce the ratios (ie, make sure the decimal form of each ratio is between 1 and 2; if it is not, double one of the numbers until it is).'''

File:How to tonality diamond 4.png|'''Optional step: to make the rows play rooted chords, one half of the diamond (not including the middle unison row) must be lowered by an octave (represented by grey cells in image).'''

Line 14:

* numerically (ie, 1 3 5 7 9 11) as in Meyer's 7-limit diamond

* ~~by tonal order~~ (ie, 1 9 5 11 3 7) as in Partch's 11-limit diamond

* tonally (ie, 1 9 5 11 3 7) as in Partch's 11-limit diamond

* chordally (ie, 1 5 3 7 9 11) as in the layout for the Diamond Marimba

Here's a short video illustrating the interlocking nature of the otonal and utonal chords and constant presence of the 1/1 interval in the 5-limit tonality diamond:

[[File:5-Limit_Tonality_Diamond_original_format.mp4|1000x400px|center]]

== History ==

The tonality diamond was first formally explained by Max F. Meyer in his 1929 publication ''The Musician's Arithmetic'' using the 7-odd-limit.<ref>[https://archive.org/details/max-f-meyer-the-musicians-arithmetic/page/22/mode/2up Meyer, Max F. "The Musician’s Arithmetic: Drill Problems for an Introduction to the Scientific Study of Musical Composition". ''The University of Missouri Studies''. Vol. 4, no. 1. University of Missouri. January 1, 1929. p. 22.]</ref>

Harry Partch is the person most associated with the tonality diamond, and ~~explains that he gives a different story for how he discovered the concept~~, it is likely ~~this source~~ that ~~gave him~~ the idea, ~~which he then extended~~ to the 11-odd-limit and ~~made~~ the ~~basis~~ of ~~his tonal system~~.

Harry Partch is the person most associated with the tonality diamond, and claimed to have invented it. However, it is likely that he plagarized the idea from Meyer.<ref>[https://www.chrysalis-foundation.org/wp-content/uploads/ThePartchHoaxDoctrines.pdf Forster, Cris (2015). ''The Partch Hoax Doctrines''. Self-published.]</ref> Regardless, his extending of the concept to the 11-odd-limit (as well as his other extensions and uses of it) was an extremely important and foundational moment in the history of xenharmonic music.

[[Erv Wilson]] in particular was inspired by Partch's use of the tonality diamond and it's extended form. He developed a number of "diamonds" himself,<ref>[https://anaphoria.com/diamond.pdf Wilson, Erv. ''Letters on Diamond Lattices, 1965–1970'' (PDF). Self-published.]</ref> as well as other concepts based on Partch's extended tonality diamond such as "constant structure."<ref>[https://www.anaphoria.com/Partchpapers.pdf Wilson, Erv. ''The Partch Papers (collection of documents on Harry Partch’s 11-limit diamond and its extensions), 1964-2002'' (PDF). Self-published.] </ref>

[[Erv Wilson]] in particular was inspired by Partch's use of the tonality diamond and it's extended form. He developed a number of "diamonds" himself,<ref>[https://anaphoria.com/diamond.pdf Wilson, Erv. ''Letters on Diamond Lattices, 1965–1970'' (PDF). Self-published.]</ref> as well as other concepts based on Partch's extended tonality diamond such as "[[constant structure]]."<ref>[https://www.anaphoria.com/Partchpapers.pdf Wilson, Erv. ''The Partch Papers (collection of documents on Harry Partch’s 11-limit diamond and its extensions), 1964-2002'' (PDF). Self-published.] </ref> A related idea of Wilson's is the "[[Cross-set scale|cross-set]]," of which the tonality diamond is a special case.

The first novel xenharmonic temperament — [[George Secor|George Secor's]] later-named "[[Miracle]]" temperament — was made to approximate Partch's 11-limit diamond.<ref>[https://www.anaphoria.com/SecorMiracle.pdf Secor, George (1975). “A New Look at the Partch Monophonic Fabric.” ''Xenharmonicon''. Vol. 3]</ref><ref>[https://www.anaphoria.com/SecorMiracle.pdf Secor, George. "The Miracle Temperament and Decimal Keyboard". ''Xenharmonikon''. Vol. 18. 2006. pp. 5–15. © 2003.]</ref>

Line 40:

Line 44:

== References ==

== External links ==

* [[wikipedia:Tonality_diamond|Wikipedia page on tonality diamonds]]

* [http://www.tonalsoft.com/enc/t/tonality-diamond.aspx Tonalsoft page on tonality diamonds]

* [https://www.chrysalis-foundation.org/musical-mathematics-pages/meyer-diamond/ Cris Forster's site on Meyer's tonality diamond]

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-  WORK-IN-PROGRESS AS OF 10MAY2025
+  Moved to [[Tonality diamond|main space]] 11 MAY 2025 by [[User:Sintel|Sintel]]
+A '''tonality diamond''' is a symmetric organization of [[Otonality and utonality|otonal and utonal]] chords based around a central note and bounded by an [[Odd limit|odd-limit]]. First formalized in the [[7-odd-limit]] by [[wikipedia:Max_Friedrich_Meyer|Max F. Meyer]] in 1929, the idea became central to the music and theories of [[Harry Partch]], who built his tonal system around the [[11-odd-limit]] tonality diamond. Tonality diamonds have been used both conceptually (such as for [[Target tuning|targets]] of [[temperaments]]) and practically (such as for instrument layouts) in xenharmonics ever since.
-A '''tonality diamond''' is a symmetric organization of [[Otonality and utonality|otonal and utonal]] chords based around a central note and bounded by an [[Odd limit|odd-limit]]. First formalized in the [[7-odd-limit]] by [[wikipedia:Max_Friedrich_Meyer|Max F. Meyer]] in 1929, the idea became central to the music and theories of [[Harry Partch]], who built his tonal system around the [[11-odd-limit]] tonality diamond. Tonality diamonds have been used both conceptually (such as for [[Target tuning|targets]] of [[temperaments]]) and practically (such as for instrument layouts) in xenharmonics ever since.
-[https://nickvuci.github.io/wiki-applets/tonalityDiamond.html '''Play some tonality diamonds to hear how they sound.''']
+'''[https://nickvuci.github.io/wiki-applets/TonalityDiamond/tonalityDiamond.html Play with tonality diamonds in your browser here.]'''
 == Construction ==
 <gallery mode="nolines" widths="200" heights="200">
 File:How to tonality diamond 1.png|'''Step 1: Take the numbers of an odd-limit and arrange them along two axes.'''
-File:How to tonality diamond 2.png|'''Step 2: Using one row as the numerator and the other as the denominator, fill in the cells with the ratios they form.'''
+File:How to tonality diamond 2.png|'''Step 2: Using one axis as the numerator and the other as the denominator, fill in the cells with the ratios they form.'''
 File:How to tonality diamond 3.png|'''Step 3: Octave-reduce the ratios (ie, make sure the decimal form of each ratio is between 1 and 2; if it is not, double one of the numbers until it is).'''
 File:How to tonality diamond 4.png|'''Optional step: to make the rows play rooted chords, one half of the diamond (not including the middle unison row) must be lowered by an octave (represented by grey cells in image).'''
@@ Line 14: / Line 14: @@
 * numerically (ie, 1 3 5 7 9 11) as in Meyer's 7-limit diamond
-* by tonal order (ie, 1 9 5 11 3 7) as in Partch's 11-limit diamond
+* tonally (ie, 1 9 5 11 3 7) as in Partch's 11-limit diamond
 * chordally (ie, 1 5 3 7 9 11) as in the layout for the Diamond Marimba
+Here's a short video illustrating the interlocking nature of the otonal and utonal chords and constant presence of the 1/1 interval in the 5-limit tonality diamond:
+[[File:5-Limit_Tonality_Diamond_original_format.mp4|1000x400px|center]]
 == History ==
 The tonality diamond was first formally explained by Max F. Meyer in his 1929 publication ''The Musician's Arithmetic'' using the 7-odd-limit.<ref>[https://archive.org/details/max-f-meyer-the-musicians-arithmetic/page/22/mode/2up Meyer, Max F. "The Musician’s Arithmetic: Drill Problems for an Introduction to the Scientific Study of Musical Composition". ''The University of Missouri Studies''. Vol. 4, no. 1. University of Missouri. January 1, 1929. p. 22.]</ref>
-Harry Partch is the person most associated with the tonality diamond, and explains that he  gives a different story for how he discovered the concept, it is likely this source that gave him the idea, which he then extended to the 11-odd-limit and made the basis of his tonal system.
+Harry Partch is the person most associated with the tonality diamond, and claimed to have invented it. However, it is likely that he plagarized the idea from Meyer.<ref>[https://www.chrysalis-foundation.org/wp-content/uploads/ThePartchHoaxDoctrines.pdf Forster, Cris (2015). ''The Partch Hoax Doctrines''. Self-published.]</ref> Regardless, his extending of the concept to the 11-odd-limit (as well as his other extensions and uses of it) was an extremely important and foundational moment in the history of xenharmonic music.
-[[Erv Wilson]] in particular was inspired by Partch's use of the tonality diamond and it's extended form. He developed a number of "diamonds" himself,<ref>[https://anaphoria.com/diamond.pdf Wilson, Erv. ''Letters on Diamond Lattices, 1965–1970'' (PDF). Self-published.]</ref> as well as other concepts based on Partch's extended tonality diamond such as "constant structure."<ref>[https://www.anaphoria.com/Partchpapers.pdf Wilson, Erv. ''The Partch Papers (collection of documents on Harry Partch’s 11-limit diamond and its extensions), 1964-2002'' (PDF). Self-published.] </ref>
+[[Erv Wilson]] in particular was inspired by Partch's use of the tonality diamond and it's extended form. He developed a number of "diamonds" himself,<ref>[https://anaphoria.com/diamond.pdf Wilson, Erv. ''Letters on Diamond Lattices, 1965–1970'' (PDF). Self-published.]</ref> as well as other concepts based on Partch's extended tonality diamond such as "[[constant structure]]."<ref>[https://www.anaphoria.com/Partchpapers.pdf Wilson, Erv. ''The Partch Papers (collection of documents on Harry Partch’s 11-limit diamond and its extensions), 1964-2002'' (PDF). Self-published.] </ref> A related idea of Wilson's is the "[[Cross-set scale|cross-set]]," of which the tonality diamond is a special case.
 The first novel xenharmonic temperament — [[George Secor|George Secor's]] later-named "[[Miracle]]" temperament — was made to approximate Partch's 11-limit diamond.<ref>[https://www.anaphoria.com/SecorMiracle.pdf Secor, George (1975). “A New Look at the Partch Monophonic Fabric.” ''Xenharmonicon''. Vol. 3]</ref><ref>[https://www.anaphoria.com/SecorMiracle.pdf Secor, George. "The Miracle Temperament and Decimal Keyboard". ''Xenharmonikon''. Vol. 18. 2006. pp. 5–15. © 2003.]</ref>
@@ Line 40: / Line 44: @@
 == References ==
+<references />
+== External links ==
+* [[wikipedia:Tonality_diamond|Wikipedia page on tonality diamonds]]
+* [http://www.tonalsoft.com/enc/t/tonality-diamond.aspx Tonalsoft page on tonality diamonds]
+* [https://www.chrysalis-foundation.org/musical-mathematics-pages/meyer-diamond/ Cris Forster's site on Meyer's tonality diamond]