User:BudjarnLambeth/Cultural appropriation-o-meter: Difference between revisions
m →Bipelog |
|||
| (47 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 62: | Line 62: | ||
=== Rating system === | === Rating system === | ||
;Passing grade, the name should be kept | ;Passing grade, the name should be kept | ||
* '''5 stars''' = Respectful name that encourages people to check out the tradition which inspired it, without claiming to be identical to that tradition | * '''5 stars''' = Respectful name that '''encourages people to check out''' the tradition which inspired it, '''without claiming to be identical''' to that tradition | ||
* '''4 stars''' = Respectful name with slight flaws, which encourages people to check out the tradition which inspired it, without claiming to be identical to that tradition | * '''4 stars''' = Respectful name with '''slight flaws''', which '''encourages people''' to check out the tradition which inspired it, '''without claiming''' to be identical to that tradition | ||
* '''3 stars''' = Name with substantial flaws, but more good points | * '''3 stars''' = Name with '''substantial flaws, but more good points''' | ||
;Failing grade, the name should be changed | ;Failing grade, the name should be changed | ||
* '''2 stars''' = Name that | * '''2 stars''' = Name that '''risks overwriting or replacing''' a tradition, '''risks falsely claiming a connection''' with that tradition, or '''risks taking from a tradition without crediting''' it | ||
* '''1 stars''' = Name that | * '''1 stars''' = Name that '''overwrites or replaces''' a tradition, or '''falsely claims connection to''' that tradition, or which takes from a tradition '''without giving credit''' | ||
<br> | <br> | ||
=== 1 star (fail) === | === 1 star (fail) === | ||
==== | ==== ''Maqamic'' ==== | ||
[[Maqamic]] temperament was a deliberate attempt to approximate Arabic [[maqam]] music with a [[regular temperament]]. So it is right for the name to reference that. | [[Maqamic]] temperament was a deliberate attempt to approximate Arabic [[maqam]] music with a [[regular temperament]]. So it is right for the name to reference that. | ||
| Line 89: | Line 82: | ||
Luckily, the name “maqamic temperament” isn’t in use anymore, and has been replaced with the imperfect, but much much better “'''neutrominant temperament'''”. | Luckily, the name “maqamic temperament” isn’t in use anymore, and has been replaced with the imperfect, but much much better “'''neutrominant temperament'''”. | ||
==== ''Slendro diesis'' ==== | |||
[[49/48]], the “slendro diesis”, doesn’t appear to have much too in common with [[slendro]], besides being tempered out in equipentatonic and quasi-equipentatonic tunings like [[5edo]] and [[semaphore]][5]. | |||
The big problem with this name is that "slendro diesis" implies that this comma is actually important to traditional, pre-[[RTT]] Indonesian music theory of the slendro scale. Which it is not. | |||
Luckily, this interval has a few other names, “'''semaphoresma'''” being the one that seems to have caught on, but “large septimal diesis” and “semaphore comma” also seeing some use. At the moment most authors use both terms, saying something like “semaphoresma a.k.a slendro diesis”. Hopefully over time, as people grow more awkward towards “slendro diesis” (which in my subjective experience seems to be already happening) they will start just saying “semaphoresma” on its own. | |||
==== Pelogic ==== | ==== Pelogic ==== | ||
| Line 96: | Line 96: | ||
===== Possible alternative names? ===== | ===== Possible alternative names? ===== | ||
* " | * "Pelographic" = "pelog approximated with RTT graphs", also sounds like "geographic" reflecting the cross cultural collaboration involved in discovering the temperament | ||
* "Pelogismic" = “a full 7 limit temperament generated by the pelogic comma” (no existing temperament is called pelogismic so the name is free) | |||
* "Peloglike" = "bears a likeness to pelog" | * "Peloglike" = "bears a likeness to pelog" | ||
* "Pelogram" = "pelog approximated with RTT diagrams" | * "Pelogram" = "pelog approximated with RTT diagrams" | ||
* " | * "Pelomatic" = "pelog approximated with mathematics" | ||
;Difficulty of renaming - Medium. There is a moderate amount written about it around the wiki. | |||
==== Srutal, shrutar, sruti ==== | ==== Srutal, shrutar, sruti ==== | ||
| Line 116: | Line 112: | ||
===== Possible alternative names? ===== | ===== Possible alternative names? ===== | ||
* "Zurutal, zurutar | * "Srutalic, shrutaran & srutinic": | ||
* | ** Resembles [[diatonic]] mode names, which makes sense on many levels | ||
* "Krutal, krutar | *** These temperaments are a compromise or a fusion between Indian shruti theory and Western diatonic-descended [[MOS]] and RTT theory, so it’s fitting for the names to be a hybrid of the two | ||
*** [[Meantone]] and its diatonic modes are a kind of ‘sister tuning’ of srutal, so it’s fitting for the names of concepts in each to be faint echoes of the other: | |||
**** both are generated by [[3/2]] | |||
**** both display exceptionally low [[complexity]] and [[badness]] in the 2.3.5 subgroup | |||
**** both have [[12edo]] as their smallest viable [[equal tuning]] | |||
* "Zurutal, zurutar & zuruti": | |||
** The letter Z looks like a big barn door with the diagonal beam to stabilise it, representing how simple yet stable srutal is and how much harmonic weight it can bear with very few notes | |||
** The letter Z looks like the long winding road the temperaments took across the world to become what they are here and now | |||
** The letter Z calls to mind the idea of “alpha and omega”, of infinity and timelessness, representing the ancient tradition of shruti, and the cyclic nature of Hindu cosmology and the way that is reflected in the cyclic nature of the [[:Category:22-tone scales|22-tone]] scale of generators and periods | |||
* "Qrutal, qrutar & qruti": | |||
** The short "q" sound represents how nimble and efficient the tunings are at approximating [[5-limit]] JI. | |||
** letter Q evokes the word “queen”, alluding to srutal’s elevated position at the top of the ranking of [[low harmonic entropy linear temperaments]] | |||
* "Krutal, krutar & kruti": | |||
** The short "k" sound represents how nimble and efficient the tunings are at approximating 5-limit JI | |||
** The letter K evokes the word “king”, alluding to srutal’s elevated position at the top of the ranking of low harmonic entropy linear temperaments | |||
;Difficulty of renaming - Very high. Lots of other temperaments are named in reference to these, lots of music and theory has been written with these, it'd be a massive pain. | |||
=== 2 stars (fail) === | === 2 stars (fail) === | ||
==== Buzurgic ==== | |||
[[169/168|Buzurgic]] temperament is named for the buzurg aka buzurk [[genus]] by [[Safi al-Din Urmavi]]. | |||
It is good that it gives credit for its inspiration, however the name is way too similar to “buzurg” to the point where musicologists could easily mix up the two, and it could serve to erase or muddy the definition of the original. | |||
The name '''dhavantaric''' has been proposed to replace “buzurgic”, however it is [[169/168#Etymology|unclear]] what the origin of that name is so it’s hard to tell if it’s better or worse by the criteria of this list. It might be a reference to a Hindu god, or to a Pali or Kannada word, in which case it is only a better name if the temperament is actually related to one of those cultures’ musical traditions, not if it is arbitrary. | |||
===== Possible alternative names? ===== | |||
* "Dhavantaric" = a proposed alternate name, but we need to check first whether it gives credit to a relevant cultural influence | |||
* "Buzzlike" = "bears a likeness to buzurg", but also refers to the buzzing sound of its pseudo-unison comma of about 10 cents | |||
* "Buzzmatic" = "buzurg approximated with mathematics", but also refers to the buzzing sound of its pseudo-unison comma of about 10 cents | |||
* "Buzurgram" = "buzurg approximated with RTT diagrams" | |||
* "Buzurgism" = named after its defining comma, the “buzurgisma”.^ | |||
<small> ^''(Not “buzurgismic”, because that is already taken by a full 7 limit temperament - “ismic” usually implies “not a subgroup temperament”, hence just “ism”) instead)'' </small> | |||
;Difficulty of renaming - Very low. I don't know of temperaments named after buzurg nor much written about it, so it should be painless to change. | |||
==== Slendric ==== | ==== Slendric ==== | ||
| Line 130: | Line 166: | ||
"Slendric" used to be called "wonder", so maybe we can bring that name back? | "Slendric" used to be called "wonder", so maybe we can bring that name back? | ||
===== ''Gamelic'' ===== | |||
Another name for slendric temperament but equally as bad. The term "gamelic" is very easily confused with the term "[[gamelan]]". That risks implying this temperament is identical to the ones used by gamelan orchestras. Which it is not. | |||
Imagine saying "gamelic scales" - musicologists could easily assume you mean "scales used in gamelan music". The potential for confusion is too high. | |||
Fortunately the name "gamelic" never really caught on and isn't widely used. | |||
===== Possible alternative names? ===== | ===== Possible alternative names? ===== | ||
| Line 137: | Line 180: | ||
* "Slendrolike" = "bears a likeness to slendro" | * "Slendrolike" = "bears a likeness to slendro" | ||
* "Slendagram" = "slendro approximated with RTT diagrams" | * "Slendagram" = "slendro approximated with RTT diagrams" | ||
* "Gamelism" = named after its defining comma, the “gamelisma”.^ | |||
<small> ^''(Not “gamelismic”, because that is already taken by a full 7 limit temperament - “ismic” usually implies “not a subgroup temperament”, hence just “ism”) instead)'' </small> | |||
;Difficulty of renaming - High. Slendric is mentioned quite a bit around the place, it is one of few temperaments to have a dedicated [[lumatone]] mapping listed on the wiki. | |||
=== 3 stars (pass) === | === 3 stars (pass) === | ||
==== Gamelismic ==== | ==== Gamelismic ==== | ||
| Line 148: | Line 192: | ||
However, “gamelismic” is at least different enough from the word “gamelan” that it’s unlikely people will confuse the two, and as a result “gamelismic” is unlikely to muddy the perception or reputation of the gamelan tradition in any way. | However, “gamelismic” is at least different enough from the word “gamelan” that it’s unlikely people will confuse the two, and as a result “gamelismic” is unlikely to muddy the perception or reputation of the gamelan tradition in any way. | ||
So | So it should be fine. | ||
==== Neutrominant ==== | ==== Neutrominant ==== | ||
"Maqamic" has been renamed to "[[neutrominant]]". While that's a big improvement, it isn’t perfect. | "Maqamic" has been renamed to "[[neutrominant]]". While that's a big improvement, it isn’t perfect. It’s good enough though, especially given how hard the community struggled internally over the name, it makes sense to keep it. Anything good enough is, well, good enough. | ||
Neutrominant was directly inspired by Arabic scales. Its explicit goal is to approximate them within an RTT framework. So the fact that its name includes no reference to Arabic music at all feels wrong. It feels a little bit like stealing from Arabic music theory and claiming it as its own without giving credit. | Neutrominant was directly inspired by Arabic scales. Its explicit goal is to approximate them within an RTT framework. So the fact that its name includes no reference to Arabic music at all feels wrong. It feels a little bit like stealing from Arabic music theory and claiming it as its own without giving credit. | ||
Neutrominant | Neutrominant is still okay, though, because it does at least still reference neutral thirds in its name, which are a concept associated with Arabic music. | ||
And also, the wiki page for neutrominant temperament does devote almost its entire length to explaining the similarities, differences and relationship with maqams (it’s a really good page), so it’s not as if the community is trying to hide the temperament’s origins, they are very enthusiastic about sharing them. | And also, the wiki page for neutrominant temperament does devote almost its entire length to explaining the similarities, differences and relationship with maqams (it’s a really good page), so it’s not as if the community is trying to hide the temperament’s origins, they are very enthusiastic about sharing them. Which makes me happy to see. | ||
==== Rishi ==== | ==== Rishi ==== | ||
| Line 169: | Line 211: | ||
Rishi gets a ''barely'' passing grade. | Rishi gets a ''barely'' passing grade. | ||
==== Slendi ==== | |||
It is unclear whether [[slendi]] temperament is related to slendro or not. If it is, then this name is very good because it gives credit without being close enough to get confused. If that’s the case, then it should be moved up to 5 stars. | |||
If it is not, however, the name is a tad too close to slendro, and risks benefiting off of an association with slendro that doesn’t exist. It isn’t close enough to warrant a name change, but it’s close enough that it can’t score any higher than 3 stars. | |||
==== Slendrismic ==== | ==== Slendrismic ==== | ||
[[Slendrismic]] temperament is not actually named after slendro, it is named after the fact it has a slender [[generator]]. For that reason it doesn't really even need to appear on this list, but we might as well give it a look. | [[Slendrismic]] temperament is not actually named after slendro, it is named after the fact it has a slender [[generator]]. For that reason it doesn't really even need to appear on this list, but we might as well give it a look. | ||
The name is similar enough to slendro that there is a tad possibility for confusion | The name is similar enough to slendro that there is a tad possibility for confusion, but it is probably different enough that it’s fine. I don’t think anyone is likely to mix up “slendro” and “slendrismic”. | ||
==== Superpelog ==== | |||
The name [[superpelog]] could give the impression that it's "better than pelog", which would be bad, but I don't think that's how most people will interpret it. | |||
I think most people will think of it as "pelog but more extreme", in the same way "[[superpyth]]" is "[[pythagorean]] but more extreme" or "[[supermajor]]" is "major but more extreme". In which the case, then the name is very good, because it gives credit to pelog without claiming to be the same as it. | |||
=== 4 stars (distinction) === | === 4 stars (distinction) === | ||
==== Bipelog ==== | |||
The name [[bipelog]] is pretty good. It gives a straightforward description of what it is (a pelog-like fifth generator, two periods per octave instead of one). It gives credit to pelog while still making it clear it’s its own thing. | |||
==== Biyatismic ==== | ==== Biyatismic ==== | ||
[[Biyatismic]] temperament is inspired by maqam biyati, so it is good that it references that in the name. | [[Biyatismic]] temperament is inspired by maqam biyati, so it is good that it references that in the name. | ||
| Line 187: | Line 238: | ||
The name is still maybe just a tad too close to the maqam, but it's pretty good. | The name is still maybe just a tad too close to the maqam, but it's pretty good. | ||
==== Buzurgismic ==== | |||
[[Buzurgismic chords|Buzurgismic]] temperament is named for the buzurg aka buzurk [[genus]] by [[Safi al-Din Urmavi]]. | |||
It is good that it gives credit for its inspiration, and the name is still distinct enough from “buzurg” that musicologists are unlikely to confuse the two, so buzurgismic will likely serve to bring much deserved attention to the original genus, rather than erasing it. | |||
==== Injera ==== | ==== Injera ==== | ||
[[Injera]] temperament is named after an Ethopian flatbread, because 26edo supports it and the Ethiopian alphabet has 26 letters. | [[Injera]] temperament is named after an [[Ethopian]] flatbread, because [[26edo]] supports it and the Ethiopian alphabet has 26 letters. | ||
Admittedly a slightly goofy reason for a name, and the temperament doesn't have much to do with Ethopia, but it's not stealing anything, and it might encourage people to check out Ethopian breadmaking, so that's quite neat. | |||
==== Kartvelian^ ==== | ==== Kartvelian^ ==== | ||
| Line 201: | Line 259: | ||
==== Migration ==== | ==== Migration ==== | ||
Closely based on [[mohajira]] temperament, [[migration]] | Closely based on [[mohajira]] temperament, the name [[migration]] is the English translation of mohajira's name, so it does still give credit indirectly by doing that, so that's why it's still rated so highly. | ||
That, combined with the fact that it is further removed from the practice of Arabic music than mohajira, so it's okay for it to give credit less directly. | That, combined with the fact that it is further removed from the practice of Arabic music than mohajira, so it's okay for it to give credit less directly. | ||
A little bit more direct credit | A little bit more direct credit might still be nice. But it's still pretty cool. | ||
==== Rastmic ==== | ==== Rastmic ==== | ||
[[Rastmic]] temperament is inspired by maqam rast, so it is good that it references that in the name. | [[Rastmic]] temperament is inspired by maqam rast, so it is good that it references that in the name. | ||
It is perhaps named a little too close to "rast", but it is probably different enough to avoid confusion. "Rastmic scale" is unlikely to be confused with "rast scale", for example. | It is perhaps still named a little too close to "rast", but it is probably different enough to avoid confusion. "Rastmic scale" is unlikely to be confused with "rast scale", for example. | ||
=== 5 stars (high distinction) === | |||
=== | ==== Biyativice ==== | ||
[[2646/2645|Biyativice]] is a vicesimotertial ([[23-limit]]) temperament [[Temper out|tempering out]] the biyatisma (same one that defines the biyatismic temperament). The name does a good job of clearly showing it’s inspired by biyati, while also showing that it’s different, and part of ''how'' it’s different (it involves [[23/1|harmonic 23]]). A very solid name! | |||
==== Mavila ==== | ==== Mavila ==== | ||
[[Mavila]] is not directly named after a traditional [[African|Chopi]] tuning, but is instead named after a village where that tuning was used. | [[Mavila]] temperament is not directly named after a traditional [[African|Chopi]] tuning, but is instead named after a village where that tuning was used. | ||
This is a great way to go about it, I think. | This is a great way to go about it, I think. | ||
What would have | What would have been bad is to call the temperament "Chopi", because then you're claiming affiliation with that entire culture, which would be appropriation. | ||
But using the name of a ''village'' instead is perfect. It gives credit to the original place where you were inspired by their tuning, without claiming to ''be'' their tuning. | But using the name of a ''village'' instead is perfect. It gives credit to the original place where you were inspired by their tuning, without claiming to ''be'' their tuning. | ||
This is actually kind of a timeless way to name scales and tunings throughout history: [[5L2s|phrygian, dorian, etc.]] are all named after geographical places, so are many of the maqams. Naming a scale after a village near where you found it is a fun strategy. | This is actually kind of a timeless way to name scales and tunings throughout history: [[5L2s|phrygian, dorian, etc.]] are all named after geographical places, so are many of the maqams. Naming a scale after a village or river or such, at or near where you found it, is a fun strategy. | ||
Important to mention, too, Mavila is actually very very close to | Important to mention, too, Mavila is actually very very close to a Chopi tuning and is directly inspired by it, so it is quite appropriate for it to have a name related to that. It's not just had the name tacked onto it, it really merits the name. | ||
===== Avila, cohemimabila, hemimabila, mabila, maviloid, mohavila, movila, trimabila ===== | ===== Avila, cohemimabila, hemimabila, mabila, maviloid, mohavila, movila, trimabila ===== | ||
| Line 246: | Line 301: | ||
==== Pelotonic ==== | ==== Pelotonic ==== | ||
Pelotonic is the [[TAMNAMS]] name for the MOS scale [[2L 5s]]. This name is awesome | Pelotonic is the [[TAMNAMS]] name for the MOS scale [[2L 5s]]. This name is awesome! | ||
2L 5s really does resemble the 7-tone version of the pelog scale, so it's quite appropriate to note that similarity in the name. | 2L 5s really does resemble the [[:Category:7-tone scales|7-tone]] version of the pelog scale, so it's quite appropriate to note that similarity in the name. | ||
"Pelotonic" is also different enough from pelog that there's no possible way of confusing or conflating the two, they're clearly different but related. That's the goal for these type of names. | "Pelotonic" is also different enough from pelog that there's no possible way of confusing or conflating the two, they're clearly different but related. That's the goal for these type of names. | ||
And even that added bit "tonic" is really smart, because it tells the theorist exactly in what way is this "pelotonic" similar to pelog: It's pelo''tonic'', it has the same number of large vs small | And even that added bit "tonic" is really smart, because it tells the theorist exactly in what way is this "pelotonic" similar to pelog: It's pelo''tonic'', it has the same number of large vs small melodic jumps as pelog. | ||
This name is perfect! | This name is perfect! | ||
| Line 262: | Line 317: | ||
These are awesome names, if only shrutar temperament itself had a name this good, given that it’s the closest one to actual shruti. Oh well. These are really good! | These are awesome names, if only shrutar temperament itself had a name this good, given that it’s the closest one to actual shruti. Oh well. These are really good! | ||
== A note about 'renaming' == | |||
A temperament or other concept does not necessarily need to be completely renamed, in order to solve its problems. Often, it may be sufficient to just add a new name, and mainly use the new name moving forwards, but not deprecate the old one. | |||
In such a case, [[composer]]s and [[:Category:Theorists|scholars]] moving forwards can choose to use the new name in order to avoid the ambiguity, confusion and colonialist vibes the old name created. While old [[software]], old theory [[The Library|papers]] and old [[Listen|music]] under the old name won't make people confused, because they won't have abandoned the old name, it will still be listed there as an "also known as" on the wiki page. | |||
In most cases, this could be the best approach to take to minimise the shock of a name change. | |||
== See also == | == See also == | ||