Xenharmonic Wiki:Manual of Style/Interval pages - Revision history

Fredg999: Increase scope

2026-06-08T03:21:38Z

Increase scope

Fredg999: Fredg999 moved page Xenharmonic Wiki:Optional guidelines for interval page todo categories to Xenharmonic Wiki:Manual of Style/Interval pages: Increase scope, move into Manual of Style

2026-06-08T03:10:36Z

Fredg999 moved page Xenharmonic Wiki:Optional guidelines for interval page todo categories to Xenharmonic Wiki:Manual of Style/Interval pages: Increase scope, move into Manual of Style

← Older revision	Revision as of 03:10, 8 June 2026
(No difference)

BudjarnLambeth: Add shorthand name “XW:IntTodo”

2025-01-03T07:18:09Z

Add shorthand name “XW:IntTodo”

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:18, 3 January 2025
Line 1:		Line 1:
	This page details optional guidelines to help wiki editors decide whether or not to put an [[interval]] page in [[:Category:Stubs]], in [[:Category:Todo:expand]], or in neither.		This page details optional guidelines to help wiki editors decide whether or not to put an [[interval]] page in [[:Category:Stubs]], in [[:Category:Todo:expand]], or in neither.

			When this page needs to be referred to in shorthand, e.g. in an edit summary, feel free to call it '''XW:IntTodo'''.

	== Guidelines ==		== Guidelines ==

BudjarnLambeth: /* Guidelines */

2025-01-03T07:11:08Z

Guidelines

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:11, 3 January 2025
Line 8:		Line 8:

	An interval page belongs in Todo:expand if it belongs to any of the following groups:		An interval page belongs in Todo:expand if it belongs to any of the following groups:
	# Pages with a total of 1 paragraph of human written text, about intervals with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice, with an odd-limit of 25 or less.		# Pages with a total of 1 paragraph of human-written text, about intervals with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice, with an odd-limit of 25 or less.
	# Pages with 1 paragraph or less of human-written text, about [[comma]]s with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice.		# Pages with 1 paragraph or less of human-written text, about [[comma]]s with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice.

BudjarnLambeth: /* Guidelines */

2025-01-03T07:04:00Z

Guidelines

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:04, 3 January 2025
Line 9:		Line 9:
	An interval page belongs in Todo:expand if it belongs to any of the following groups:		An interval page belongs in Todo:expand if it belongs to any of the following groups:
	# Pages with a total of 1 paragraph of human written text, about intervals with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice, with an odd-limit of 25 or less.		# Pages with a total of 1 paragraph of human written text, about intervals with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice, with an odd-limit of 25 or less.
	# Pages with 1 paragraph or less of human-written text, about [[comma]]s with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice		# Pages with 1 paragraph or less of human-written text, about [[comma]]s with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice.

BudjarnLambeth: /* Guidelines */

2025-01-03T07:03:53Z

Guidelines

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:03, 3 January 2025
Line 8:		Line 8:

	An interval page belongs in Todo:expand if it belongs to any of the following groups:		An interval page belongs in Todo:expand if it belongs to any of the following groups:
	# Pages with a total of 1 paragraph of human written text, about intervals with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice, ~~which are either [[commas]] or have~~ an odd-limit of 25 or less.		# Pages with a total of 1 paragraph of human written text, about intervals with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice, with an odd-limit of 25 or less.
			# Pages with 1 paragraph or less of human-written text, about [[comma]]s with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice

BudjarnLambeth: Created page with "This page details optional guidelines to help wiki editors decide whether or not to put an interval page in :Category:Stubs, in :Category:Todo:expand, or in neithe..."

2025-01-03T06:54:52Z

Created page with "This page details optional guidelines to help wiki editors decide whether or not to put an interval page in Category:Stubs, in Category:Todo:expand, or in neithe..."

New page

This page details optional guidelines to help wiki editors decide whether or not to put an [[interval]] page in [[:Category:Stubs]], in [[:Category:Todo:expand]], or in neither.

== Guidelines ==
An interval page belongs in Stubs if it belongs to any of the following groups:
# Pages with 1 sentence or less of human-written text.
# Pages with ''less than'' 1 paragraph of human-written text, about intervals with at least moderately far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice, with an [[odd-limit]] of 25 or less.

An interval page belongs in Todo:expand if it belongs to any of the following groups:
# Pages with a total of 1 paragraph of human written text, about intervals with large, far-reaching impacts on xenharmonic theory and practice, which are either [[commas]] or have an odd-limit of 25 or less.

All interval pages that do not belong to one of the above groups, should not be in Stubs nor Todo:expand.

== History ==
Following a discussion in [[Xenharmonic Wiki talk:Things to do]], a Google Forms survey was run by [[Budjarn Lambeth]] from Jan 1 to Jan 3 2025 (Sydney time). The survey was posted on the Wiki's Facebook, its Discord, and the aforementioned talk page. 4 wiki editors voted. Lambeth himself did not vote.

The survey asked in which circumstances an interval page should be in Category:Stubs, in Category:Todo:expand, or in neither of those.

Based on the results, Lambeth created the guidelines.

=== Survey results ===
==== Key ====
(^^) Indicates the winning option.

(??) Indicates an unresolvable tied winner.

==== Winner determination method ====
# If any option has >50% of the votes, it wins.
# If every option has 50% or less, then eliminate the last placed option and reallocate its votes as follows:
## "EXPAND" --> "STUBS"
## "STUBS" --> "EXPAND"
## "NEITHER" --> "STUBS"
# Whichever option has the most votes afterwards wins; if it's a tie, then the result is indeterminate
# If there is a tie for last place between "neither" and another option, then treat "neither" as last and the other option as second last (eliminate "neither") - this is because neither wouldn't have a chance to win if it were second last given how preferences are allocated.
# If there is a tie between "stubs" and "expand" for last place, then treat "expand" as last and "stubs" as second last (eliminate "expand") - this is because "expand" is a much smaller category on the wiki, more easily overloaded by too many new pages at once, so it's better for controversial edge cases to go to "stubs" instead.

==== Results by factor ====
Factors sorted from apparent strongest to weakest.

<pre>All 2+ paragraph pages
NEITHER 75% (^^)
EXPAND 25%
STUBS 0%

All 0.1-paragraph pages
STUBS 75% (^^)
NEITHER 25%
EXPAND 0%

All high integer limit pages
NEITHER 67% (^^)
STUBS 25%
EXPAND 8%

All 1-paragraph pages
NEITHER 59% (^^)
EXPAND 28%
STUBS 13%

All narrow application pages <2 paragraph
NEITHER 58% (^^)
STUBS 42%
EXPAND 0%

All medium application pages <2 paragraph
NEITHER 54% (^^)
STUBS 25%
EXPAND 21%

All low integer limit pages
STUB 42% (^^)
NEITHER 42%
EXPAND 16%

All comma pages
EXPAND 50% (??)
NEITHER 50% (??)
STUB 0%

All 0.5-paragraph pages
NEITHER 50% (??)
STUBS 44% (??)
EXPAND 6%

All wide application pages <2 paragraph
NEITHER 50% (??)
EXPAND 31% (??)
STUBS 19%</pre>

==== Raw results ====
<pre>Wide application, low numerals, 0.5 paragraph
STUBS 50% (^^)
EXPAND 25%
NEITHER 25%

Wide application, low nums, 1 paragraph
NEITHER 50% (??)
STUBS 25% (??)
EXPAND 25%

Wide application, comma, 1 paragraph
NEITHER 50% (??)
EXPAND 50% (??)
STUBS 0%

Wide application, high nums, 1 paragraph
NEITHER 75% (^^)
EXPAND 25%
STUBS 0%

Wide application, 2-3 paragraph
NEITHER 75% (^^)
EXPAND 25%
STUBS 0%

Moderate application, low numerals, 0.5 paragraph
STUBS 50% (??)
NEITHER 50% (??)
EXPAND 0%

Moderate application, high numerals, 0.5 paragraph
STUBS 50% (??)
NEITHER 50% (??)
EXPAND 0%

Moderate application, simple comma, 1 paragraph
EXPAND 50% (??)
NEITHER 50% (??)
STUBS 0%

Moderate application, low nums, 1 paragraph
NEITHER 50% (??)
STUBS 25% (??)
EXPAND 25%

Moderate application, complex comma, 1 paragraph
EXPAND 50% (??)
NEITHER 50% (??)
STUBS 0%

Moderate application, high nums, 1 paragraph
NEITHER 75% (^^)
STUBS 25%
EXPAND 0%

Narrow application, 0.1 paragraph
STUBS 75% (^^)
NEITHER 25%
EXPAND 0%

Narrow application, 0.5 paragraph
NEITHER 75% (^^)
STUBS 25%
EXPAND 0%

Narrow application, 1 paragraph
NEITHER 75% (^^)
STUBS 25%
EXPAND 0%</pre>

[[Category:Xenharmonic Wiki]]